EVEN 2909: Introduction to Global Sustainability
University of Colorado Boulder
Tuesday
The global food system: who eats what, and where the crops go.
Food security: the four pillars, hunger and famine.
The food–water–energy nexus: groundwater, cooking fuel, and Colorado’s version of it.
Thursday
How we got here: Haber-Bosch and the Green Revolution.
The footprint of food: what you eat versus where it comes from.
Livestock, alternative proteins, loss and waste.
Soil carbon and regenerative agriculture: what the evidence supports.
Feeding 9.7 billion people: EAT-Lancet 2019 and 2025.
Keep your notes from Tuesday’s warm-up; we use them again Thursday.
Pick one thing you ate or drank this morning. With a neighbor, write down:
Guesses are fine. Keep the list; Thursday you will estimate its footprint.
Who eats what, and where the crops go
The food system leaves 645 million people hungry and 2.5 billion adults overweight, including 890 million living with obesity. It also produces about a third of human greenhouse gas emissions (16 Gt CO2e in 2022) and uses 44% of the world’s habitable land.
World population is expected to peak around 10.3 billion in the 2080s. Most of the growth before 2050 is in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia, where hunger is already highest.
UN World Population Prospects 2024; FAO SOFI 2026; WHO obesity fact sheet (2022 data); Crippa et al., Nature Food 2021 (34%); FAOSTAT Analytical Brief 94 (2024); Our World in Data, land use.
Framework adapted from HLPE Report 12, Nutrition and Food Systems (2017).
Kern County, California, grows about 593 billion calories a year, a quarter of them vegetables, and ships them to hundreds of counties across the West.
Food Twin is a model of the US food system that traces crops from the county where they are grown to the counties where they are eaten, and can simulate disruptions to farms and roads to see which counties lose supply.
It was built by Zia Mehrabi’s Better Planet Lab in CU Boulder’s Environmental Studies program, with The Plotline (Earth Genome) and Development Seed.
Try it after class: look up Boulder County as a consumer. Where does your food come from, and which of those places is short of water?
Better Planet Lab, CU Boulder; The Plotline; CU Boulder Today, 21 November 2023.
Wheat, rice and maize eaten as food supply 40% of the 3,016 kcal available per person per day. Plants supply 82%, animal products 18%. Much more maize is grown than this: most of it is fed to animals or turned into fuel.
| Use | Share |
|---|---|
| Eaten directly by people | 55% |
| Animal feed | 36% |
| Biofuels and other industrial uses | 9% |
Only about 12% of feed calories come back as meat, milk and eggs. In the US, 36.5% of the 2024/25 corn crop went to fuel ethanol.
Ask the class: the world grows enough calories for everyone. Why are 645 million people hungry?
FAOSTAT Food Balances, world, 2023; Cassidy et al., Environmental Research Letters 2013; USDA WASDE, September 2026.
Livestock uses 77% of farmland (pasture plus feed crops) and supplies 18% of the world’s calories and about 40% of its protein.
Our World in Data, based on Poore & Nemecek, Science 2018 and FAO.
Enough food is necessary, and it is not sufficient
“Food security exists when all people, at all times, have physical, social and economic access to sufficient, safe and nutritious food which meets their dietary needs and food preferences for an active and healthy life.”World Food Summit 1996, as revised by FAO in 2001
Availability
Is there enough food, from harvests, stocks, trade and aid?
Access
Can people get it? Income, prices, markets, roads, social protection.
Utilization
Can the body use it? Diet quality, clean water, sanitation, health.
Stability
Do the other three hold through droughts, price spikes and conflict?
In 2020 the UN High Level Panel of Experts proposed two more: agency, people’s ability to decide what they eat and how it is produced, and sustainability, meeting today’s needs without undermining future food security.
FAO; HLPE Report 15, Food Security and Nutrition: Building a Global Narrative towards 2030 (2020).

645 million people (7.8%) were chronically undernourished in 2025, down from 673 million in 2024.
About 2.1 billion were moderately or severely food insecure.
Hunger is falling in Asia and Latin America and rising as a share of the population in much of sub-Saharan Africa. FAO projects about 520 million people will still be hungry in 2030, against a Sustainable Development Goal 2 target of zero.
FAO et al., The State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World (SOFI) 2025 and 2026.

Stunting
Low height for age, from years of poor diet and repeated infection. Linked to lower schooling and earnings as adults, and largely irreversible after age two.
Wasting
Low weight for height (more than two standard deviations below the WHO growth standard), from recent, severe weight loss caused by too little food or by infections such as diarrhea. A wasted child has a higher risk of death, but it can be treated.
The double burden
Many countries, and many households, now have undernourished children and overweight adults at the same time. Cheap calories are easy to get; a diverse diet is not.
Only 28% of countries are on track to meet the global stunting target.
UNICEF/WHO/World Bank Joint Child Malnutrition Estimates 2025 (2024 data); WHO (2022 data); WHO, Malnutrition fact sheet.
The Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) grades acute food insecurity from 1 to 5. Famine (Phase 5) requires hunger, acute malnutrition and deaths all above set thresholds in the same area.

Every recent famine has been driven by conflict.
Global Report on Food Crises 2026; IPC Famine Review Committee; WHO, 22 August 2025.
Bengal, 1943
About 3 million people died. Amartya Sen showed that the 1943 rice harvest was larger than the harvest of 1941, a year with no famine. What collapsed was entitlement: wartime inflation and speculation pushed rice prices far above what laborers, fishers and artisans earned. Food left rural areas for Calcutta and the army while the people who grew it starved.
Ireland, 1845–1852
About one million people died and over a million emigrated. Here the crop failure was real: potato blight destroyed three-quarters of the 1846 harvest, and most smallholdings were too small to feed a family on any crop but potatoes. Yet large quantities of food, including cattle, were exported from Ireland throughout, and London refused to bar those exports as it had in earlier famines. Relief was cut back on laissez-faire grounds, and families holding more than a quarter acre were denied workhouse aid.
Sen later observed that no major famine has occurred in a functioning democracy with a free press, because governments that face elections and newspapers act before people starve.
For engineers: a model that predicts harvests does not predict hunger. You also need wages, prices, markets and who has the power to move food.
Sen, Poverty and Famines: An Essay on Entitlement and Deprivation (1981); Sen, Development as Freedom (1999). Later demographic estimates of Bengal deaths are closer to 2.1 million. Kinealy, This Great Calamity: The Irish Famine 1845–52 (1994).
| Episode | FAO Food Price Index peak |
|---|---|
| 2007–08: oil prices, biofuel mandates, export bans | 132.7 (Jun 2008) |
| 2010–11: drought in Russia, poor harvests | 137.7 (Feb 2011) |
| 2022: Russia’s invasion of Ukraine | 160.2 (Mar 2022) |
| August 2026 | 133.3 |
FAO Food Price Index, 2014–16 = 100, current revised series.
March 2022 is the highest value in the index. Russia and Ukraine were major exporters of wheat, maize, sunflower oil and fertilizer, and countries that import most of their grain, such as Egypt and Lebanon, were exposed.
Poor households spend a much larger share of their income on food than rich ones, so a price spike that is an inconvenience in Boulder can push a family in Cairo or Nairobi into hunger.
The Famine Early Warning Systems Network, created by USAID in 1985 after the Ethiopian famine, combines satellite rainfall and vegetation data, market prices and field reports to forecast food insecurity months ahead.

Work from this group in northern Kenya: 69 sensors on rural boreholes, combined with satellite data and machine learning, forecast where groundwater demand will outstrip supply 1 to 4 months before a drought peaks. FEWS NET and Kenya’s National Drought Management Authority use the forecasts to decide where to send water trucks.
Fankhauser, Sharpe, Wilson & Thomas, CU Boulder. See the intro slides.
Ask: who should pay for early warning, and what happens when it goes dark?
Devex, June 2025; NPR, 31 August 2026.
The world grows enough calories for everyone. Hunger persists because of who can afford food, and where fighting, weather and falling aid cut people off from it.
Poverty and the price of a good diet
2.69 billion people, 33% of the world, could not afford a healthy diet in 2025. It cost $4.28 a person a day (PPP), up from $3.44 in 2021. In Africa, 67% could not afford it, and Africa now accounts for 309 million of the world’s hungry.
Conflict
Conflict and insecurity were the leading driver of acute food insecurity in 2025. More than 80% of people in acute food insecurity live in protracted crises, where one emergency runs into the next.
Weather extremes
Weather was the main driver for 87.5 million people in 16 countries in 2025, up from 15.7 million in 2020. El Niño is expected to last into early 2027, with drought risk across southern Africa.
Less help
Humanitarian aid from donor countries is projected to fall 40% between 2024 and 2026. Food aid is falling faster, and the data systems that track hunger are at risk.
FAO et al., SOFI 2026; Global Report on Food Crises 2026; European Commission Joint Research Centre, 2026 (OECD aid projections).
Put money in people’s hands
Cash transfers and social protection let poor households buy food when prices spike. Delivering cash usually costs less than shipping food, though which works better depends on whether local markets have food to sell. They improve diets, but their effect on child growth is small.
Act before the shock
Before forecast floods in Bangladesh in 2020, WFP sent about two weeks of food money by mobile phone to more than 23,000 very poor households. Recipients were 36% less likely to go a day without eating. Forecasts are only useful if money is ready to move on them.
Make healthy food cheaper
70–75% of what consumers pay is added after the farm gate. SOFI 2026 calls for roads, cold chains, irrigation and research, and for reforming subsidies and trade rules that raise prices.
Invest in smallholders
Ceres2030 estimated that about $33 billion a year more, $14 billion from donors and $19 billion from affected countries, could lift 490 million people out of hunger by 2030. It also found that most agricultural research does not address smallholders’ problems.
Conflict is the leading driver, and none of these tools works where aid cannot get in. Which of these are engineering problems?
Gentilini, World Bank 2016 (cash versus food); Manley, Alderman & Gentilini, BMJ Global Health 2022; Pople, Hill, Dercon & Brunckhorst, Oxford CSAE 2021; FAO et al., SOFI 2026; Ceres2030, Nature Research journals, 2020.
For each case, name the pillar (availability, access, utilization, stability, agency) that failed first, and one intervention that would address it.
You cannot change one without moving the other two
A policy aimed at one system changes the other two. Some examples:
FAO AQUASTAT 2025; FAO, Energy-Smart Food for People and Climate (2011); USDA WASDE September 2026.
A water footprint counts rainwater used by crops (green water), irrigation from rivers and aquifers (blue water) and the water needed to dilute pollution (grey water). Most of beef’s footprint is green water in feed and pasture, which matters less than blue water in a dry basin. A kilogram of irrigated almonds in California and a kilogram of rain-fed beef in Ireland stress water supplies very differently.
FAO AQUASTAT Water Data Snapshot 2025; Mekonnen & Hoekstra, Science Advances 2016; Mekonnen & Hoekstra, Ecosystems 2012 and HESS 2011.
High Plains (Ogallala) aquifer


Underlies eastern Colorado, Kansas, Nebraska, Texas and four other states, and irrigates much of the US corn, wheat and cattle feed.
Recharge in the southern High Plains is a fraction of an inch a year, so this water is effectively not renewable on human timescales.
California’s Central Valley

Grows about a quarter of the nation’s food and accounts for 20% of US groundwater demand. Half of the water used in the valley is groundwater.
The High Plains and the Central Valley together account for about half of US groundwater depletion since 1900.
USGS Scientific Investigations Report 2023-5143; Kansas Geological Survey 2025; USGS, California’s Central Valley; Scanlon et al., PNAS 2012.

Punjab is India’s wheat and rice bowl, and a Green Revolution success story.
On the High Plains and in Punjab, the price of energy sets how fast the water is pumped.
Rodell et al., Nature 2009; Central Ground Water Board; The Tribune, 2025.



Processing, refrigeration, transport, retail and cooking use more energy than the farm itself. For 2 billion people, cooking means wood, charcoal or kerosene: household air pollution is a leading risk factor in the Global Burden of Disease, and fuel collection falls mostly on women and children. Boiling water on the same fires adds to the demand; carbon finance for household water treatment is built on displacing that wood.
FAO, Energy-Smart Food for People and Climate (2011); IEA et al., Tracking SDG7 2026.
“First in time, first in right.” The oldest water rights, many held by farms and ditch companies since the 1800s, are filled first in a dry year. Front Range cities are junior users with growing populations (Colorado grew 14.8% from 2010 to 2020).
Cities buy senior agricultural rights and move the water to town, and the farmland goes out of production. Alternative transfer methods lease water from farms only in dry years and keep fields producing the rest of the time.
Most of Colorado’s irrigation water grows hay, alfalfa and corn, much of it fed to cattle and dairy cows. Cattle are more than half of the state’s farm income.
Earlier snowmelt and hotter summers leave less water in late season, when crops need it most.
USDA NASS Colorado Agricultural Profile 2024 and 2022 Census of Agriculture; Colorado Water Plan 2023.


Front Range cities, including Boulder through the Colorado–Big Thompson Project, pipe Colorado River water east under the Continental Divide.
US Bureau of Reclamation, Post-2026 Operations Record of Decision (2026); Colorado River Compact (1922); US–Mexico Water Treaty (1944).
Aquifers are falling from Kansas to California to Punjab, the Colorado River is promised more water than it carries, and growing cities want the water farms use now. In every case, agriculture uses most of the water.
Price it
Charge for groundwater, or for the electricity to pump it.
Cap it
Set limits on pumping and river diversions, and enforce them.
Move it
Let cities buy or lease water from farms, outright or only in dry years.
Need less of it
Change irrigation methods, crops or diets so less water is needed per person fed.
Discuss: Which would you try first, and where? Who pays, and who loses: farm families, rural towns, city ratepayers, the river itself? Would your answer hold in a hotter, drier 2050? 7 minutes in groups, then one minute per group.
Before Thursday: bring your breakfast list. Skim Our World in Data, Environmental Impacts of Food Production.
The footprint of diets, soil carbon and regenerative agriculture
Order these from highest to lowest greenhouse gas emissions per kilogram of food, farm to retail. Then find your breakfast ingredient.
kg CO2e per kg of food, global mean. Beef is 100 times peas by weight.
Poore & Nemecek, Science 2018, via Our World in Data.
Synthetic nitrogen, the Green Revolution, and the bill
Carrying capacity is the largest population an environment can sustain with the food, water and other resources it has. For two centuries, serious people warned that humanity was about to hit that ceiling and fall into mass famine.
1798 · Thomas Malthus
Population grows geometrically, doubling every 25 years, while food grows only arithmetically. The gap ends in famine unless birth rates fall.
World population: 1.0 billion
1898 · William Crookes
The wheat-eating nations would start running out of food in the 1930s, because natural sources of nitrogen fertilizer were running out. He called on chemists to take nitrogen from the air.
World population: 1.6 billion
1968 · Paul and Anne Ehrlich
The Population Bomb opened: “The battle to feed all of humanity is over.” Hundreds of millions would starve in the 1970s, whatever was done.
World population: 3.5 billion
Each time, the ceiling moved. Haber and Bosch answered Crookes within 15 years, and the Green Revolution was already under way when The Population Bomb came out. The world now feeds 8.2 billion people, though 645 million are still chronically hungry.
Malthus, An Essay on the Principle of Population (1798); Crookes, presidential address to the British Association (1898); Ehrlich, The Population Bomb (1968); world population from Our World in Data (HYDE, Gapminder, UN WPP).
In 1909 Fritz Haber showed that nitrogen from the air could be combined with hydrogen to make ammonia. Carl Bosch scaled it into an industrial process by 1913.
N2 + 3H2 → 2NH3, at roughly 400–500 °C and 150–300 atmospheres, with hydrogen made mostly from natural gas.
Before this, crop nitrogen came from manure, legumes and mined guano and saltpeter. Synthetic fertilizer removed that ceiling on yields.

Erisman et al., Nature Geoscience 2008; IEA Ammonia Technology Roadmap 2021.
The Green Revolution was the spread of high-yielding crop varieties, planted together with fertilizer, irrigation and pesticides, first in Mexico and then across South and Southeast Asia from the mid-1960s. A USAID administrator, William Gaud, named it in 1968.
Disease-resistant wheat
Borlaug, a plant pathologist from Iowa, went to Mexico in 1944 with a Rockefeller Foundation program and bred wheat that resisted stem rust, a fungus that was wrecking harvests.
Shuttle breeding
He grew two generations a year at sites about 1,000 km apart, one in the Sonora lowlands and one in the highlands near Mexico City. This halved breeding time, and the varieties stopped depending on day length, so they grew at many latitudes.
Short stems
Tall wheat given heavy fertilizer grew big heads and fell over. In 1953 he began crossing in a Japanese semi-dwarf, Norin 10, whose short, stiff stems could carry the extra grain.
Results
By 1963, 95% of Mexico’s wheat was his varieties and the harvest was six times that of 1944. From 1965 to 1970, wheat yields nearly doubled in India and Pakistan. IRRI’s IR8 rice, released in 1966, averaged 9.4 tonnes per hectare in trials, against 1–2 tonnes on Philippine farms. Borlaug received the Nobel Peace Prize in 1970.

Nobel Prize biography of Norman Borlaug (1970); Wikipedia, Norman Borlaug and Green Revolution (citing Hesser, The Man Who Fed the World, 2006); IRRI, Rice Today, on IR8.
From 1961 to 2020, world cereal production rose 3.45-fold while the area harvested grew 13.5% and population grew 2.57-fold. High-yield varieties, irrigation, fertilizer and pesticides drove the gain.
Our World in Data from FAOSTAT.
| Flow | Now | Boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Nitrogen fixed for agriculture (Tg N/yr) | 190 | 62 |
| Phosphorus to the ocean (Tg P/yr) | 22.6 | 11 |
These are two of the planetary boundaries from the climate science lecture. Food systems account for nearly all of the transgression.
Richardson et al., Science Advances 2023; EAT-Lancet Commission 2025.

Nitrogen and phosphorus from farms across the Mississippi basin, which drains 41% of the lower 48 states, feed algal blooms in the Gulf. When the algae die and sink, their decay strips oxygen from the bottom water.
| Year | Hypoxic area (sq mi) |
|---|---|
| 2024 | 6,705 |
| 2025 | 4,402 |
| 2026 | 1,332 |
| Goal: five-year average by 2035 | under 1,900 |
2026 was small because Tropical Storm Bertha mixed the water just before the survey, not because runoff fell.
NOAA National Centers for Coastal Ocean Science; LUMCON; Mississippi River/Gulf of Mexico Hypoxia Task Force.
What you eat, how it is produced, and what gets thrown away
For most foods, land-use change and the farm stage dominate. Transport is about 6% of food emissions overall.
Our World in Data, based on Poore & Nemecek, Science 2018.
Where food comes from matters much less than what it is.
These are real benefits. They are separate from the carbon footprint and should be argued on their own terms.
Poore & Nemecek, Science 2018; Our World in Data, "You want to reduce the carbon footprint of your food? Focus on what you eat, not whether your food is local."
The footprint of beef varies more between producers than between beef and chicken on average.
| kg CO2e per 100 g protein | Value |
|---|---|
| Beef, median producer | 25 |
| Beef, highest-impact 10% of producers | over 105 |
| Beef, lowest-impact 10% of producers | under 9 |
| Lamb, lowest-impact producers | 12 |
| Tofu, highest-impact producers | 3.5 |
| Nuts, highest-impact producers | 2.4 |
| Peas, highest-impact producers | 0.8 |
Across all foods, the highest-impact 25% of producers create 53% of each product’s environmental impact.
Better farming narrows the range within a food. Even the lowest-impact beef and lamb still emit more than the highest-impact plant proteins, so switching foods moves the number further than switching farms.
Poore & Nemecek, Science 2018; Our World in Data, "Less meat is nearly always better than sustainable meat."
Rice paddies add about 9% of anthropogenic methane.
The feed additive 3-NOP (3-nitrooxypropanol, sold as Bovaer) blocks the enzyme rumen microbes use in the last step of making methane. At the recommended dose it cut methane per kilogram of feed by about 26% in confinement-fed beef and dairy cattle. Other options are better herd health and productivity, manure digesters, and eating less ruminant meat.
FAO, Pathways towards Lower Emissions (2023); Saunois et al., Global Methane Budget, ESSD 2025; Duin et al., PNAS 2016; Macdonald et al., Frontiers in Animal Science 2025.

Roads cut into the forest in the 1970s and 1980s, settlers cleared along them in the fishbone pattern, and most of the cleared land became cattle pasture. Pasture accounts for about half of the tropical deforestation that ends up in agricultural production.
Pendrill et al., Science 2022; USGS EROS.
Plant-based
Burgers and milks made from soy, pea and wheat protein. On sale everywhere; sales growth has slowed since 2021 on price and taste.
Precision fermentation
Engineered microbes make specific proteins such as whey, casein or egg white. Already used in some ice cream and baking ingredients.
Cultivated meat
Animal cells grown in bioreactors. Cleared in the US: chicken from UPSIDE and GOOD Meat (2023), Wildtype salmon and Mission Barns pork fat (2025).
Florida and Alabama banned sales in 2024; Mississippi, Montana, Nebraska, Indiana and Texas in 2025; South Dakota in 2026. A federal appeals court upheld Florida’s ban in March 2026.
Investment fell from $139M in 2024 to $74M in 2025. Believer Meats closed in December 2025 after raising about $390M. Published costs are company claims; none has been independently audited.
Ask: should a state be able to ban a food that federal regulators have found safe? Who benefits?
Council of State Governments Midwest, May 2026; Good Food Institute; Calcalist, 2025.

FAO Food Loss Index; UNEP Food Waste Index Report 2024; IPCC Special Report on Climate Change and Land (2019).
What the practices do, and what the evidence supports

In the 1910s and 1920s, high wheat prices and new tractors pushed plowing across the southern Great Plains, including southeastern Colorado. When drought came in the 1930s, the bare soil blew away.
Storms carried Plains soil as far as Washington, DC. Hundreds of thousands of people left the region.
Congress created the Soil Conservation Service in 1935, now the Natural Resources Conservation Service. Its tools, such as contour plowing, shelterbelts, cover crops and paying farmers to retire fragile land, are the ancestors of today’s regenerative practices.
Soil holds about 3.3 times as much carbon as the atmosphere and 4.5 times as much as all living plants and animals. Plowing, draining and overgrazing released a large share of it; the 116 Gt lost equals roughly a decade of today’s fossil CO2 emissions.
Salt build-up affects about 10% of irrigated and 10% of rain-fed cropland.
“Only 60 harvests left” is widely quoted and has no traceable source. A 2020 global analysis found a median soil lifespan of about 500 years under current erosion, with a minority of soils, mostly on steep or intensively tilled land, lasting under a century.
Lal, Science 2004; Sanderman et al., PNAS 2017, corrected 2018; FAO & ITPS, Status of the World’s Soil Resources 2015; UNCCD Global Land Outlook 2017; FAO, Global Status of Salt-Affected Soils 2024; Evans et al., Environmental Research Letters 2020.
There is no single legal definition of regenerative agriculture. Most programs combine some of these practices, aiming to rebuild soil organic matter and biodiversity while staying productive.
No-till and reduced tillage
Plant directly into last season’s residue. Cuts erosion and fuel use. Usually relies more on herbicides to control weeds.
Cover crops
Rye, clover or radish grown between cash crops to hold soil, feed soil life and, for legumes, add nitrogen.
Diverse rotations
Rotating more crops, including legumes and perennials, breaks pest cycles and reduces fertilizer needs.
Managed grazing
Moving animals often between paddocks to let grass recover.
Agroforestry
Trees planted among crops or pasture for shade, windbreaks, fruit, timber and carbon in wood.
Compost and manure
Organic inputs that replace some synthetic fertilizer and add organic matter.

Benefits for erosion, water infiltration and drought resilience are well documented for several of these. The climate claims are where the evidence gets thin.
Powlson and colleagues (2014) found no-till’s climate benefit “widely overstated.” Much of the apparent carbon gain is carbon moved closer to the surface, where it is sampled, with less below. Some no-till soils also emit more nitrous oxide.
The Food Climate Research Network’s review, Grazed and Confused (2017), found grazing could at best offset 20–60% of emissions from grazing systems, 4–11% of all livestock emissions, and 0.6–1.6% of global emissions. The gain is “small, time-limited, reversible and substantially outweighed” by the animals’ own emissions.
Launched by France at COP21 in 2015, it set an aspirational goal of raising soil carbon 0.4% a year. Long-term field data, including 170 years of Rothamsted plots in England, show that rate is rarely reached at scale without large added inputs.
Powlson et al., Nature Climate Change 2014; Garnett et al., Grazed and Confused, FCRN 2017; Poulton et al., Global Change Biology 2018; van Groenigen et al., Environmental Science & Technology 2017.
Carbon credit programs (for example under Verra’s VM0042 methodology, now version 2.2) pay farmers for adopting practices, and sell the resulting tonnes as offsets. The hard part is proving the tonnes are real.
You can only pay for an outcome you can measure. Water programs face the same problem: payment for safe water depends on monitoring that shows the water is safe.
We return to carbon markets later in the course.
Bradford et al., Geoderma 2023; SOIL 11:17 (2025); Saifuddin et al., Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 2024; Verra VM0042 v2.2.
Most of these cut inputs per unit of food on large, well-capitalized farms.
Farms under 2 hectares work about 12% of the world’s farmland. Few can buy sensors or GPS tractors; mobile phones, weather and price text messages, and shared equipment services reach them more often.
Lowder, Sánchez & Bertini, World Development 2021.
Maize losses show up before 2040 in several major growing regions. Wheat gains come mostly from high latitudes and CO2 fertilization, while tropical wheat and rice face heat stress at flowering.
Jägermeyr et al., Nature Food 2021 (SSP5-8.5, end of century); IPCC AR6 WGII Chapter 5.
“Food is the single strongest lever to optimize human health and environmental sustainability on Earth.”EAT-Lancet Commission, 2019
Willett et al., The Lancet 2019; Rockström, Thilsted, Willett et al., The Lancet, 3 October 2025.
About 2,400 kcal a day, mostly whole grains, vegetables, fruit, legumes and nuts, with modest amounts of dairy, fish and poultry.
For the average American, this means eating much less red meat and more legumes and nuts. For many people in low-income countries, it means eating more animal-source food, vegetables and fruit.
Critics argue the diet is unaffordable for many low-income households, underweights nutrients from animal foods for children and pregnant women, and is set globally for very different food cultures. The 2025 Commission responded in part by widening the ranges.
EAT-Lancet Commission 2019 and 2025 summary reports.
Hunger is mostly about access
The world grows enough calories. Prices, incomes, conflict and health decide who eats.
Food, water and energy are one problem
Agriculture takes 72% of freshwater withdrawals and about 30% of energy; energy and water policy are food policy.
What you eat outweighs where it comes from
Transport is about 6% of food emissions. Ruminant meat and dairy dominate.
Soil practices help soil more than climate
Regenerative practices reduce erosion and improve water retention. Their carbon gains are smaller, reversible and hard to measure.
Loss and waste are about a third of food
13% lost before retail, 19% wasted after, 8–10% of global emissions.
Next week: Water Infrastructure & Treatment: Systems & Contaminants. With co-instructor Whitney Knopp.