Keys: S toggles these notes, R reveals answers on quiz slides, Esc opens the slide overview. Thursday starts at the green dots on the right edge (the "Thursday" divider). Budgets in these notes total about 73 minutes on Tuesday and 75 on Thursday.
This Week
Tuesday
How much material the economy moves, and how little comes back. Can recycling and efficiency keep up with growth? Jason Hickel’s critique. Proof that material systems can change fast. Linear and circular models: the butterfly diagram and the R-ladder. Life cycle assessment: functional units, boundaries, and results that surprise. Embodied carbon: cement, steel, aluminum and timber.
Thursday
Plastics: production, recycling, the ocean, and the treaty talks. Textiles and fast fashion: where clothes go and what is changing. E-waste and the critical minerals behind the energy transition. Planned obsolescence, and designing for circularity: disassembly, repair, product-as-a-service, industrial symbiosis. Hickel’s case for degrowth, repair coming back, and where this can go. Colorado’s new packaging law and what Boulder does with its trash.
Keep Tuesday’s warm-up list; Thursday’s redesign activity starts from it.
1 min.
Warm-up · 5 minutes · pairs
Your last 24 hours of trash
List everything you threw away, recycled or composted since this time yesterday. For each item, write:
What it was made of.
Which bin it went in, and whether you were sure.
How long you used it before it became waste.
Circle the item with the shortest useful life.
5 min. Collect two or three "shortest life" items aloud (cup lids, receipts and delivery packaging are common). Ask how many people were unsure about a bin; Thursday’s warm-up answers it for Boulder County.
Part 1
The Material Economy
What we dig up, what we build, and what comes back
We Extract More Than Three Times What We Did in 1970
Global extraction rose from 30.9 billion tonnes in 1970 to 95.1 billion in 2020, and the UN Resource Panel expects about 106.6 billion for 2024. That is 13.2 tonnes per person.
The fastest growth is in sand, gravel and other building minerals: 31% of the total in 1970, 48% in 2020.
Extracting and processing these materials causes more than 55% of greenhouse gas emissions and over 90% of land-use biodiversity loss and water stress.
On current trends, extraction reaches about 160 billion tonnes by 2060.
Source: UNEP International Resource Panel, Global Resources Outlook 2024, pp. 26–27 and key messages. 2024 is an estimate; 2060 is a projection.
3 min. Ask what the gold block is: concrete, asphalt and brick, mostly for buildings and roads in Asia. The 55% emissions figure excludes land-use change; with it, resource-related climate impacts exceed 60%. Biomass here includes food and feed crops, so it overlaps with last week.
Human-Made Mass Now Outweighs All Living Things
In 1900, everything humans had built weighed about 3% of the planet’s living biomass. Around 2020 (±6 years) the two crossed, at about 1.1 trillion tonnes each.
We now add about 30 billion tonnes of buildings, roads, machines and products a year. Per person, that is more than your body weight every week.
Most of that mass is concrete and aggregate in buildings and infrastructure. It is also the largest potential “mine” for future materials, if it is designed to come apart.
Buildings and infrastructure vs. trees and shrubs
Buildings & infrastructure
1,100 Gt
Trees & shrubs
900 Gt
Plastic vs. all animals
Plastic
8 Gt
All animals
4 Gt
Dry mass, 2020. The two charts use different scales.
Source: Elhacham et al. (2020), Global human-made mass exceeds all living biomass, Nature 588:442.
2 min. "Animals" includes humans, livestock, fish and insects. Biomass is dry weight; counting water in living things would move the crossover later, which the paper discusses.
The Circularity Gap
106 Gt
Materials entering the economy, 2021
6.9%
Of it secondary (recycled) material
93.1%
Virgin material
Of the 106.1 billion tonnes that entered the global economy in 2021, 7.3 billion came from recycled sources.
Using the same method, the share was 7.2% in 2018. It is falling because total use is growing faster than recycling.
Why the ceiling is low
Fuel, food and feed are consumed: in 2005, 44% of all processed materials went to energy and could not be recycled.
Buildings and roads lock material up for decades: 17 billion tonnes (27%) were added to stocks that year.
What is recycled is mostly metal, paper and construction rubble.
Sources: Haas et al. (2015), J. Industrial Ecology 19:765 (2005 figures); Circle Economy, Circularity Gap Report 2025 (data year 2021); the 2026 report repeats these figures.
2 min. Earlier editions headlined 9.1% (2018 report) and 8.6% (2020 report); the method changed between editions, so those are not a time series. Use 7.2% to 6.9% as the like-for-like comparison. Some food can be made circular through composting and nutrient recovery, so the 44% is an upper bound on what is lost.
Can Recycling Keep Up With Growth?
Jason Hickel argues that recycling alone cannot make a growing economy sustainable.
Growth outruns recycling
Recycling grows every year, yet the recycled share falls. A smaller share of a larger total still means more virgin extraction.
Loops cost energy
Collecting, sorting and reprocessing take money and energy, and most materials lose quality each cycle. Virgin material stays cheap because the damage from extracting it is left off the price.
Easier without growth
He supports making the economy as circular as possible, and argues that it is far easier once total throughput stops growing.
Is the circular economy a way to keep growing, or a way to need less?
Source: Hickel (2020), Less is More, ch. 3, “What about recycling?”
2 min. Hickel cites the 9.1% and 8.6% headlines as a decline; the like-for-like series on the previous slide makes the same point. Take two answers to the callout question and hold them for Thursday’s degrowth slide.
Relative vs. Absolute Decoupling
Relative decoupling
Material use grows, but more slowly than GDP. Common.
Absolute decoupling
Material use falls while GDP grows. What a sustainable growing economy would need.
Per person, the gap is large
Hickel puts high-income countries at about 28 tonnes of material per person per year and low-income countries at about 2. Global use (106 Gt) is about double the 25–50 Gt sustainable range Bringezu (2015) proposed.
Three reasons for doubt
Accounting. Rich countries’ domestic material use has flattened, but counting the materials used abroad to make their imports, the decoupling shrinks or disappears. Across 186 countries, material footprint rises about 6% for every 10% rise in GDP.
Rebound. Jevons (1865): more efficient steam engines raised Britain’s coal use, because cheaper power expanded production. Hickel’s example: a chainsaw does not give loggers the afternoon off; it fells ten times the trees.
Physics. Models with very optimistic efficiency gains find decoupling is temporary: use falls, then rises again with growth.
Hickel and Kallis conclude that green growth is unlikely, and suggest decoupling well-being from GDP rather than GDP from materials.
Sources: Wiedmann et al. (2015), PNAS 112:6271; Ward et al. (2016), PLoS ONE 11:e0164733; Hickel & Kallis (2020), New Political Economy 25:469; Hickel (2020), Less is More, chs. 2–3.
3 min. Hickel’s per-person figures are from materialflows.net for about 2017, and Bringezu’s range is as Hickel cites it. Carbon is different from materials: some rich countries have cut emissions while growing, and Hickel and Kallis argue the rate is far too slow for 1.5 or 2 °C. A 2024 comment on Ward et al. (Bercegol & Brockway, arXiv:2401.12100) corrects their GDP data and finds even less relative decoupling, while agreeing absolute decoupling is implausible. Services do not escape it either: Hickel notes high-income countries have the largest service sectors and the largest material footprints.
Linear vs. Circular
Linear: take, make, waste
Extract
→
Make
→
Use
→
Dispose
Value is created once, at the sale. A product that breaks sooner sells another product.
Working face of a landfill. Photo: Ashley Felton, public domain.
Circular: the Ellen MacArthur Foundation’s three principles
1. Eliminate waste and pollution
Treat waste as a design decision made upstream.
2. Circulate products and materials at their highest value
Keep a working phone in use before shredding it for copper.
3. Regenerate nature
Return biological materials to soil; shift from extraction to restoration.
Source: Ellen MacArthur Foundation, Circular economy introduction.
3 min. Ask for one product whose business model depends on it wearing out (printer cartridges, fast fashion, phones with glued batteries). Principle 2 is the one engineers act on most directly.
The Butterfly Diagram
Two kinds of material move in different loops.
Biological cycle
Food, wood, cotton. Use them in cascades, then return the nutrients to soil by composting or digestion.
Technical cycle
Metals, plastics, electronics. The inner loops keep the product whole and keep more of the value and embodied energy. Recycling is the outer loop: it keeps the atoms but loses the product.
Mixing the two breaks both: plastic in compost contaminates the soil, and food in a landfill makes methane.
Simplified from the Ellen MacArthur Foundation’s circular economy systems diagram (2019), which draws on Braungart & McDonough, Cradle to Cradle.
3 min. The full EMF diagram is at ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/circular-economy-diagram if you want to show it from the browser; EMF does not license it for reuse, so it is redrawn here. Point out that each step outward costs more energy and loses more value.
The R-Ladder: Which Loop First?
R0RefuseMake the product unnecessary, or meet the need another way
R1RethinkUse it more intensively: sharing, multi-use products
R2ReduceUse less material and energy to make and run it
R3ReuseAnother user takes it as is
R4RepairFix it so it keeps working
R5RefurbishRestore and update an old product
R6RemanufactureUse its parts in a new product with the same function
R7RepurposeUse it or its parts for a different function
R8RecycleProcess the material, to the same or lower grade
R9RecoverBurn it for energy
R0–R2: smarter use and manufacture
Decided by designers, business models and users before anything is made.
R3–R7: extend the life of the product
Keeps the shape and function, and the energy that went into them.
R8–R9: useful application of materials
Where most recycling programs operate. Last resort before landfill.
Higher rungs usually save more, but not always. Life cycle assessment is how you check.
Source: Potting et al. (2017), Circular Economy: Measuring Innovation in the Product Chain, PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, Fig. 2.1.
3 min. Run one object up the ladder with the class: a laptop. R0 is a shared lab machine, R4 is a battery swap, R6 is a refurbished business laptop, R8 is the shredder. Compare with the old waste hierarchy (prevent, reduce, reuse, recycle, recover, dispose); the R-ladder splits "reuse" into five steps.
Part 2
Life Cycle Assessment
Counting impacts from cradle to grave
What an LCA Is
A life cycle assessment adds up everything a product takes from the environment and everything it gives back, from raw material to disposal, for one unit of service.
1. What service?
“Carry a week of groceries home,” not “one bag.” The unit decides the answer.
2. What is inside the boundary?
Just the factory (cradle-to-gate), or the whole life (cradle-to-grave)? Compare products only on the same boundary.
3. Which impacts count?
Carbon, water, toxicity and more. A product can win on one and lose on another.
ISO 14040 and 14044 (2006) formalize this as goal and scope, inventory, impact assessment, interpretation.
3 min. Keep it to the picture: inputs in, outputs out, add them up for one unit of service. The ISO four stages (goal and scope, inventory, impact assessment, interpretation) are the formal version of the three questions, and in practice interpretation sends you back to fix the scope or fill gaps. Hold allocation for a question if it comes up: when one process makes two products (a dairy farm makes milk and beef) you must split the impacts, and different splits give different answers. The impact categories in full: climate change (kg CO2e), ozone depletion, acidification and eutrophication, water use, human and ecosystem toxicity, mineral resource depletion. The bag example comes back with real numbers on the Danish EPA slide.
Quiz · 5 minutes
How Many Uses to Beat a Plastic Bag?
A Danish EPA study compared shopping bags with a thin plastic (LDPE) grocery bag that is reused once as a bin liner. How many times must each alternative be used to match it? Write down a guess for each.
BagClimate only · All impacts
Bleached paper bag1 · 43
Woven polypropylene tote (the common store tote)5 · 45
Polyester bag2 · 35
Conventional cotton tote52 · 7,100
Organic cotton tote149 · 20,000
Cotton’s worst category is ozone depletion, from cotton farming. The study treated litter as negligible in Denmark, so it does not count plastic bags in rivers and oceans, where they do worst.
Source: Danish EPA (2018), Life Cycle Assessment of Grocery Carrier Bags, Environmental Project No. 1985, Table IV.
6 min. 3 min guessing, 3 min discussion. "All impacts" means the number of uses needed to match the plastic bag on every one of 15 impact categories; it is set by whichever of 15 categories is worst for that bag. The report was not peer reviewed, and Danish groups criticized how the cotton results were presented. Ask: does this mean plastic bags are good? The useful answer is that the result depends on the functional unit, the categories counted, and what was left out (marine litter). Reuse whatever bag you already own as many times as you can.
Another Surprise: Drying Your Hands
Grams of CO2e per pair of dried hands
High-speed dryer (Airblade)
4.4
High-speed dryer (XLERATOR)
7.9
Cotton roll towel
10.2
Paper towels, virgin
14.6
Paper towels, 100% recycled
14.8
Standard warm-air dryer
17.2
Recycled paper towels came out slightly worse than virgin ones: in this study, making a recycled towel emitted a little more (6.08 vs. 5.96 g CO2e).
The old warm-air dryer was worst, because it runs for a long time.
Dyson paid for the study. With uncertainty included, the peer-reviewed version found the high-speed dryers clearly lower, but could not separate the warm-air dryer, cotton towels and paper towels from each other.
Ask of any LCA: who paid, what was the functional unit, and how big is the uncertainty?
Sources: Montalbo, Gregory & Kirchain (2011), Life Cycle Assessment of Hand Drying Systems, MIT Materials Systems Laboratory, Table 8; Gregory et al. (2013), Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 18:1605.
3 min. The functional unit is one pair of dried hands, with measured dry times and an assumed number of towels per use (the paper result is sensitive to whether people take one towel or two).
Activity · 12 minutes · groups of 3–4
Scope an LCA
Pick one comparison. You are not calculating; you are writing the goal and scope a real study would need.
Reusable vs. disposable cup at a campus coffee shop.
Printed textbook vs. e-reader.
E-scooter share vs. walking vs. your own bike.
Buying a new phone every two years vs. keeping one for five.
Write down:
Functional unit: what service, how much, for how long.
Boundary: which life cycle stages are in, and one thing you are leaving out.
The three biggest flows you expect, and which stage they sit in.
One impact category where the answer might flip.
11 min. 8 min in groups, 4 min report from two groups with different comparisons. Push on the functional unit: "one cup" vs. "a semester of daily coffee"; the reusable cup’s washing water and energy is what groups usually forget. For the scooter, walking’s "fuel" is food, which links to last week.
Part 3
Embodied Carbon
The emissions you pay up front
Embodied vs. Operational Carbon
~37%
Of global CO2 from buildings & construction
~50%
Of global material extraction goes into buildings
~½
Of new-construction emissions to 2050 are embodied
Embodied carbon is the emissions from extracting, making, transporting and installing materials, plus maintenance and demolition. Operational carbon is the heating, cooling, lighting and appliances over the building’s life.
Operational carbon falls as grids get cleaner and buildings get more efficient. Embodied carbon is emitted before the building opens and cannot be reduced later.
Ways to reduce it
Reuse and retrofit existing buildings.
Use less material: efficient structural design, avoid over-specifying concrete strength.
Choose lower-carbon versions of the same material (blended cement, scrap-based steel).
Substitute materials where the functional unit allows it (timber for some concrete and steel).
Sources: GlobalABC/UNEP, Global Status Report for Buildings and Construction 2025–2026, p. 36; Architecture 2030, New buildings: embodied carbon.
3 min. The 37% includes building operations (about 26% of energy-related CO2) plus the cement, steel and aluminum used in buildings. We go deeper on buildings next week; today is about the materials.
Carbon per Kilogram Is the Wrong Comparison
Embodied carbon, kg CO2e per kg (cradle-to-gate)
Concrete (with 25% slag)
0.12
Concrete (global avg.)
0.18
Softwood lumber
0.26
Cross-laminated timber
0.44
Glass
1.44
Steel rebar
1.96
Aluminum (global mix)
13.0
Timber values exclude carbon stored in the wood.
Concrete has the lowest carbon per kilogram on this list, yet cement, its binder, is one of the largest single sources of CO2 (next slide).
A concrete beam may need many times the mass of a steel beam for the same job, so per-kilogram numbers say little until you fix what the beam has to do.
The right functional unit is “a floor that carries this load over this span for 60 years,” not “a kilogram.”
Steel rebar ranges from 0.4 (scrap in an electric arc furnace) to 4.0 (iron ore in a blast furnace): a tenfold spread within one material.
Source: IStructE (2022), How to Calculate Embodied Carbon, 2nd ed., Table 2.3 (drawing on the ICE database and EPDs).
3 min. Callback to the LCA functional unit. The ICE database (University of Bath / Circular Ecology) is free for education after registration if students want to look up their own materials.
Cement: Emissions From the Chemistry Itself
4+ Gt
Cement made per year
~8%
Of global CO2
>50%
From the limestone itself
CaCO3 + heat → CaO + CO2
Cement is made by heating limestone to about 1,450 °C in a kiln. The reaction releases CO2 no matter what fuel heats the kiln, so clean energy alone cannot fix cement. About 40% of the sector’s emissions come from fuel and the rest mostly from the limestone.
Options
Replace part of the clinker with slag, fly ash, calcined clay or ground limestone.
Use less cement per structure: design to the strength actually needed.
Capture the CO2 at the kiln and store it.
An 84 m rotary kiln at the Rohrdorf cement works, Germany. Photo: Schmidti, CC BY-SA 3.0.
Sources: Lehne & Preston (2018), Making Concrete Change, Chatham House, pp. 6, 18; IPCC 2006 Guidelines Vol. 3 Ch. 2.
3 min. The IEA puts the limestone share at about two-thirds and the sector at about 7% of CO2; Chatham House says over 50% and 8%. The Global Carbon Project counts only the limestone (process) emissions: 1.47 billion tonnes of CO2 in 2024. Kiln temperature is the standard clinkering temperature.
Steel: Three Ways to Make It
1,886 Mt
Steel made, 2024
2.18 t
CO2e per tonne, world average
7–8%
Of global greenhouse gases
Iron ore is iron bonded to oxygen. To make steel you have to pull the oxygen off, and what you pull it off with decides the emissions.
1. Blast furnace: with coal
Today’s route, about 7 in 10 tonnes. Iron ore + coke → iron + CO2 The carbon in the coal takes the oxygen and leaves as CO2. About 2.3 t CO2 per tonne of steel.
2. Direct reduction: with hydrogen
New, at pilot scale (HYBRIT, Sweden). Iron ore + hydrogen → iron + water Hydrogen takes the oxygen and leaves as water. Low-carbon only if the hydrogen is made with clean electricity.
3. Electric arc furnace: melt scrap
The circular route, about 3 in 10 tonnes. Old steel + electricity → new steel No ore, so no oxygen to remove. About 0.7 t CO2 per tonne, less on clean power. Limited by how much scrap exists.
Recycling cannot do it alone: demand is still growing, and the steel in today’s buildings and cars will not become scrap for decades. New ore-based steel is needed, which is why the hydrogen route matters.
Sources: worldsteel, World Steel in Figures 2025 and Climate action open forum (2024 data); route intensities are worldsteel CO2 data collection averages.
3 min. The chemistry if asked: blast furnace Fe2O3 + 3 CO → 2 Fe + 3 CO2; hydrogen route Fe2O3 + 3 H2 → 2 Fe + 3 H2O. The 2.18 t world average is scope 1–3 across all routes; 75% of the sector’s 4.1 Gt is direct. Route splits are worldsteel 2023 crude steel by process (oxygen about 71%, electric about 29%). Callback to the material stock slide: steel in use is still accumulating, so scrap supply lags demand.
Aluminum: Where Recycling Pays Off Most
Per tonne of aluminum
Energy, primary (GJ)
186
Energy, recycling (GJ)
8.3
CO2e, primary (t)
15.1
CO2e, recycling (t)
0.52
Recycling figure is the remelting process only (gate-to-gate), not collection and sorting.
Making new aluminum means splitting aluminum oxide with electricity, which takes a lot of it. Remelting scrap takes about 5% as much.
The sector emitted about 1.1 billion tonnes of CO2e in 2018, around 2% of global emissions. Where the smelter’s electricity comes from (coal in China, hydropower in Iceland or Quebec) sets most of the primary number.
A can that is recycled can be back on a shelf as a can. Most plastics cannot do that, which is Thursday’s topic.
Sources: International Aluminium Institute, recycling energy and emissions pages (primary 2022, energy 2019); Bayliss et al., ICSOBA 2021.
2 min. IAI cautions that 0.52 t is the remelt step only; adding collection, sorting and alloying raises it, but recycling still saves well over 90%. The "can back on the shelf" point is the industry’s own marketing line; the physics supports it because aluminum does not degrade on remelting, though alloy mixing limits some uses.
Building With Timber
Katajanokan Laituri, Stora Enso’s timber headquarters, under construction in Helsinki, 2023. Photo: Pekka Vyhtinen, CC BY 4.0.
Mass timber panels (cross-laminated timber, glulam) can replace concrete and steel in floors, walls and frames up to mid-rise and taller buildings.
The case for it
Across 18 side-by-side comparisons of mid-rise buildings, mass timber designs averaged 69% lower construction-stage emissions than concrete or steel. Whole-building studies that include foundations and enclosure find 21–43%.
The wood stores carbon for the life of the building.
Panels can be designed to come apart and be reused.
The questions to ask
Where did the wood come from, and does the forest regrow?
What happens at end of life: reuse, landfill or burning?
Fire, moisture and acoustics add material elsewhere.
Sources: Himes & Busby (2020), Wood buildings as a climate solution, Developments in the Built Environment; WoodWorks, Mass Timber Comparative LCA Series (four US buildings).
2 min. Whether stored carbon should be counted as a credit is contested in LCA practice: it depends on the forest’s regrowth time and on what happens to the wood after the building. EN 15804 reports it separately for that reason.
Material Systems Can Change Fast
When a material is clearly harmful and the rules change, use can fall within a year, and damaged systems start to heal.
The ozone layer is healing
The 1987 Montreal Protocol has eliminated about 99% of the ozone-depleting substances it banned. The 2022 scientific assessment projects recovery to 1980 levels by about 2040 over most of the world, 2045 over the Arctic and 2066 over Antarctica.
A 15-cent charge on plastic bags
Ireland’s 2002 levy cut estimated use from about 328 bags per person a year to about 21 within the year. When use crept back up, the levy was raised in 2007, and use fell again.
The tools in this unit, from LCA to extended producer responsibility, are how the next of these gets designed.
Sources: WMO/UNEP Scientific Assessment of Ozone Depletion 2022; Oireachtas written answer, 6 June 2012, and Irish local authority levy pages.
2 min. End Tuesday on this. The Irish numbers are estimates from levy receipts; usage rose to about 31 per person by 2006 before the higher levy brought it down to 16 by 2011, which is also a lesson in watching for rebound.
Exit ticket · 3 minutes
Before You Leave
Name one product you own where the use phase probably dominates its life cycle, and one where manufacturing does.
Which rung of the R-ladder could you move your circled warm-up item up to?
One question about Tuesday you want answered Thursday.
Thursday: plastics, e-waste, critical minerals, and designing products to come back.
3 min. Collect on paper or the course form. Skim the questions before Thursday and answer two in the first five minutes.
Thursday
Plastics, Electronics and Designing for Return
Two hard waste streams, and how to design around them
1 min. Recap Tuesday in one sentence: extraction has tripled since 1970, under 7% of what enters the economy is recycled, and LCA is how you check whether a "greener" option really is.
Warm-up · 5 minutes
Which Bin? Boulder County Curbside
Recycle cart, or not? Vote by show of hands.
Plastic grocery bagNo: CHaRM
Paper coffee cupNo: trash
Clear #1 plastic iced-coffee cupNo
Clear #1 plastic clamshell (berries, salad)Yes
Aluminum foil, balled upYes (2″+ ball)
Foam takeout containerNo: trash
AA batteriesNo: hazardous waste
The #1 cup and the #1 clamshell are the same polymer. Whether something is accepted depends on whether the sorting machines can catch its shape and whether a buyer wants the bale.
Sources: Boulder County, Recycling materials list; Eco-Cycle, What to recycle curbside in Boulder County.
5 min. Film and bags wrap around the sorting screens at the materials recovery facility, which is why they go to CHaRM instead. Batteries go to the county hazardous materials facility at 1901 63rd St; lithium batteries in carts start fires in trucks and sorting plants. Balled foil needs to be at least two inches across or it falls through the screens with glass.
Part 4
The Plastics Problem
Production, fate, recycling, and the ocean
The Graduate (1967, dir. Mike Nichols). Film still, copyright its rights holder; used for teaching.
1 min. Ask who recognizes the scene: Mr. McGuire’s one-word career advice to Benjamin. In 1967 the world made about 23 million tonnes of plastic; in 2019, 460 million (next slide).
Plastic Production: 2 Million Tonnes in 1950, 460 Million in 2019
Production doubled between 2000 and 2019.
On current policies the OECD projects 1,231 million tonnes a year by 2060, with waste rising from 353 to 1,014 million tonnes.
Industrial machinery, road marking paint and marine coatings: under 1% combined.
Other uses, 14%: not assigned to a sector in the data.
Packaging is used for months or less, so it made up about 40% of 2019’s plastic waste. Pipes and window frames last decades.
Sources: Geyer et al. (2017) and OECD Global Plastics Outlook (2022), plastics use by application, via Our World in Data.
2 min. Hover the line to show values. If the network fails: 1950 2 Mt, 1970 35 Mt, 1990 120 Mt, 2000 213 Mt, 2010 313 Mt, 2019 460 Mt.
Where Plastic Ends Up
Plastic waste generated in 2019 (353 million tonnes)
Recycled 9%
Incinerated 19%
Landfilled 50%
Mismanaged or leaked 22%
All plastic waste ever generated, to 2015 (6,300 million tonnes)
9%
Incinerated 12%
Landfilled or in the environment 79%
Of the 8,300 million tonnes of virgin plastic made up to 2015, about 6,300 had already become waste. At current trends, 12,000 million tonnes will be in landfills or the environment by 2050.
“Mismanaged” means open dumps, open burning, or leakage to land and water. Most of it happens where waste collection is incomplete, and some of it is waste that rich countries exported.
Sources: OECD (2022), Global Plastics Outlook; Geyer, Jambeck & Law (2017), Science Advances 3:e1700782.
3 min. The 9% recycled is collected for recycling; losses in sorting and reprocessing mean less than that becomes new plastic. Compare with the 6.9% circularity figure from Tuesday.
Why Plastic Is Hard to Recycle
Many polymers that look alike. PET, HDPE, PVC, LDPE, PP, PS and many blends must be separated, and the resin code (#1–7) on a product says nothing about whether it is accepted.
Additives and colors travel with the polymer and limit what it can become.
Each melt shortens the polymer chains, so most recycled plastic becomes a lower-grade product (a bottle becomes carpet fiber), which is downcycling.
Multi-layer packaging (chip bags, pouches) bonds several materials that cannot be separated.
Sorting lines at the Sims materials recovery facility, Brooklyn. Photo: JelloMistress, CC BY-SA 4.0.Baled PET bottles awaiting sale, San Jose, California. Photo: Grendelkhan, CC BY-SA 4.0.
3 min. PET bottles and HDPE jugs are the two plastics with steady markets; that is why the cup and clamshell in the warm-up are treated differently (shape and market, not polymer). "Chemical recycling" breaks polymers back to monomers or oil; at commercial scale most of it so far produces fuel, which on the R-ladder is recovery, not recycling.
When China Stopped Taking It: National Sword
24
Categories of waste banned from Jan 2018, incl. plastics & mixed paper
0.5%
Contamination limit on what was still allowed
1.4 Mt → 50 kt
EU plastic waste exports to China, 2016 → 2018
US scrap plastic exports fell from 3.7 billion pounds in 2017 to 2.4 billion in 2018. China’s share of them fell from 33% to under 5%.
An estimated 111 million tonnes of plastic waste will have nowhere to go by 2030 because of the ban. For years, part of the rich world’s “recycling rate” was waste shipped to places with weaker controls.
Sources: Resource Recycling (2019), U.S. scrap plastic exports fell 35%; Eurostat (2020); Brooks, Wang & Jambeck (2018), Science Advances 4:eaat0131.
1 min. Since 1 January 2021, the Basel Convention plastic waste amendments require the importing country’s prior consent for most mixed or contaminated plastic waste; clean, sorted PE, PP and PET are exempt.
Plastic in the Ocean
Rivers carry 0.8 to 2.7 million tonnes of plastic to the ocean each year. More than 1,000 rivers account for 80% of it, many of them small rivers through dense cities; 44 of the top 50 are in Asia.
Plastic from the Pasig and Pampanga rivers in Manila Bay, 2008. Photo: Shubert Ciencia, CC BY 2.0.
In the model, emissions are driven by mismanaged waste close to rivers and coasts, and by rainfall.
Source: Meijer et al. (2021), More than 1000 rivers account for 80% of global riverine plastic emissions into the ocean, Science Advances 7:eaaz5803. Map via Our World in Data.
2 min. The older Jambeck et al. (2015) estimate was 4.8–12.7 million tonnes for 2010, from all coastal sources, not only rivers; the two numbers measure different things. The Philippines has the largest share on the map, then India and Malaysia. The model is known to overestimate the Pasig River. Ask what a US consumer can and cannot change here: collection systems abroad, and exports of mixed plastic.
Microplastics and Health
Microplastics are pieces under 5 mm, from broken-down litter, tire wear, synthetic textile fibers and industrial pellets. They have been found in seawater, soil, air and human tissue.
One study to know: Marfella et al., NEJM 2024
Surgeons removed plaque from the neck arteries of 304 patients. Polyethylene was found in 58% of the plaques. Over about three years, patients with plastic in their plaque had 4.5 times the risk of heart attack, stroke or death (95% CI 2.0–10.3).
The study was observational: it shows an association, not that plastic caused the events. People with more plastic exposure may differ in other ways. It is a reason for more research.
Microplastic particles from an ocean sample. Photo: 5 Gyres, courtesy Oregon State University, CC BY-SA 2.0.
Source: Marfella et al. (2024), Microplastics and nanoplastics in atheromas and cardiovascular events, N. Engl. J. Med. 390:900. 257 of 304 patients completed follow-up.
2 min. This connects to the Global Health week on how to read observational studies. PVC was found in 12% of plaques.
The Global Plastics Treaty
2022UN Environment Assembly agrees to negotiate a binding treaty
→
Busan, Dec 2024INC-5 ends without agreement
→
Geneva, Aug 2025INC-5.2: 11 days, no treaty
→
Feb 2026New chair elected (Chile’s Julio Cordano)
→
Mar 2027Next session scheduled
The main split
The High Ambition Coalition, more than 100 countries, wants a cap on new plastic production and limits on harmful chemicals. The “Like-Minded” group, mostly oil producers such as Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Iran and Russia, wants a treaty on waste management only, and insists on decisions by consensus.
Why it matters for engineers
A production cap acts on R0–R2 of the ladder. A waste-only treaty acts on R8–R9. Product design rules (reusable, recyclable, no problem additives) sit in between.
Sources: Eco-Business (Dec 2024); Packaging Insights (Aug 2025); Seven Seas Media (Feb 2026); Economie Circulaire (2026) on INC-5.4 dates.
2 min. As of late October 2026 there is no treaty. The INC-5.4 dates come from secondary reporting; check UNEP’s INC page before class in case they changed. The US and India were reported to oppose a production cap at Geneva. Over 80 countries rejected the chair’s final-day text there.
Colorado Makes Producers Pay for Recycling
Colorado diverted 15.7% of its waste from landfill in 2024.
The 2022 Producer Responsibility law (HB22-1355) moves the cost of recycling packaging and paper from towns and residents to the companies that sell it. Producers pay fees to a nonprofit, the Circular Action Alliance, which funds collection and processing statewide.
Fees are set higher for packaging that is hard to recycle, which gives the designer a reason to choose differently.
2022 Law signed
Jan 2024 Statewide needs assessment
Jul 2025 Producers must join to sell packaging in Colorado
Dec 2025 State approves the program plan
Jan 2026 First producer dues paid
2026 Program starts funding towns and facilities
2035 Goal: more than double the recycling rate for packaging and paper
Sources: Colorado General Assembly, HB22-1355 (requires eco-modulated fees); Circular Action Alliance, Colorado program updates (Dec 2025–Oct 2026); Eco-Cycle & CoPIRG, State of Recycling and Composting in Colorado, 9th ed. (2025), via Waste Dive.
2 min. Colorado was the third state to pass a packaging EPR law, after Maine and Oregon (2021), and just ahead of California (2022). Oregon’s program started first, in July 2025. The law requires the fee schedule to raise dues on packaging that is hard to recycle. In October 2026 the program added 13 recycling facilities. The fee design (eco-modulation) is the part that reaches the design table.
Fashion’s Material Footprint
132 Mt
Fiber produced worldwide, 2024
59%
Of it polyester, mostly from oil and gas
<1%
Of fiber made from recycled textiles
19 kg
Textiles bought per person in the EU, 2022
More clothes, worn fewer times
From 2000 to 2015, clothing production roughly doubled while the average number of times a garment was worn fell by 36%.
The equivalent of one garbage truck of textiles is landfilled or burned every second.
Where the impacts land
Land, water and climate: in the EU, textiles rank fourth among household purchases for environmental and climate pressure, after food, housing and transport, and third for water and land use.
Microplastics: washing synthetic clothes releases an estimated 16–35% of the primary microplastics reaching the ocean.
Workers: the 2013 Rana Plaza factory collapse in Bangladesh killed about 1,134 garment workers.
Sources: Textile Exchange, Materials Market Report 2025; European Environment Agency, textiles briefings (2020 rankings, 2022 consumption); Ellen MacArthur Foundation (2017), A New Textiles Economy; Boucher & Friot (2017), IUCN, and EEA (microplastics range).
2 min. 88% of polyester is fossil-based; recycled polyester is about 12% of polyester, almost all from PET bottles, not old clothes. The “doubled” and “36%” figures are from the 2017 Ellen MacArthur report and compare 2015 with 2000. A 2025 EEA briefing ranks textiles fifth, not fourth, across 12 consumption categories. Rana Plaza death tolls range from 1,127 (ILO) to 1,138 (Clean Clothes Campaign). Connect back to the cotton tote in Tuesday’s bag quiz and to the 10% textile share of plastic use.
Where Clothes Go, and What’s Changing
Where donated clothes end up
Kantamanto market, Accra, Ghana
One of the world’s largest secondhand markets. The Or Foundation estimates about 15 million garments arrive in Ghana each week and that about 40% leave the market unsold, as waste. Traders and resellers repair, restyle and resell much of the rest.
Atacama Desert, Chile
Of roughly 60,000 tonnes of used clothing shipped to northern Chile each year, up to 39,000 tonnes are reported dumped in the desert.
What is working
Factory safety: the Accord that brands and unions signed after Rana Plaza has run about 56,000 inspections at more than 2,400 Bangladeshi factories and fixed over 140,000 hazards.
Producers pay: the EU has required separate textile collection since January 2025, and by April 2028 makers of clothing, shoes and household textiles must fund collection and recycling, with higher fees for less durable products.
France’s 2026 law puts a per-item penalty on ultra-fast fashion and bans its advertising from 2027.
Secondhand is growing: US secondhand apparel grew about 14% in 2024, several times faster than clothing overall.
For clothing, the functional unit is a wear. A shirt worn 100 times beats a “greener” one worn 5 times.
Sources: Or Foundation, via Fashion Dive and BusinessDay (2023); news reports on Alto Hospicio, Chile (2021); International Accord for Health and Safety; Directive (EU) 2025/1892; Loi n° 2026-602 du 8 juillet 2026; ThredUp/GlobalData Resale Report 2025.
2 min. The 40% is contested: Ghana’s used-clothing dealers’ association found under 5% of a bale is unusable on arrival, and the Or Foundation’s own 2022 bale study found about 4%; the 40% is what leaves the market unsold. The Or Foundation argues for producer responsibility rather than an import ban, because the ban would cut livelihoods without touching overproduction. France’s penalty starts at under €1 per item in 2026 and rises toward €20 by 2030, capped at half the price, with details set by decree. The ThredUp figures are industry estimates. The callout is the LCA functional-unit idea from Tuesday applied to clothes.
Part 5
E-Waste and Critical Minerals
The materials of the energy transition
E-Waste: The Fastest-Growing Waste Stream
62 Mt
E-waste generated, 2022
7.8 kg
Per person
22%
Documented as properly collected and recycled
82 Mt
Projected for 2030
What is inside
The metals in 2022’s e-waste were worth about $91 billion: copper $19B, iron $16B, gold $15B. Only $28 billion of that was recovered.
A tonne of discarded phones holds about 340 g of gold. Rich gold ore holds about 18 g per tonne.
Rare earth elements are about 1% recovered.
The ledger
Handling e-waste the way the world does now costs society a net $37 billion a year: $78 billion in health and environmental damage and $10 billion in treatment, against $28 billion in recovered metal and $23 billion in avoided emissions.
The share that is properly recycled is expected to fall to 20% by 2030, because e-waste is growing faster than collection.
Sources: UNITAR/ITU, Global E-waste Monitor 2024; Rao et al. (2020), RSC Advances 10:4300 (gold content).
3 min. The ITU attributes the $78 billion in damage mainly to lead and mercury emissions, plastic leakage and greenhouse gases. The gold comparison is from a review by Rao, Singh, Morrison & Love (2020).
Where the Other 78% Goes
Burning cable for copper at Agbogbloshie, Accra, Ghana, 2019. Photo: Muntaka Chasant, CC BY-SA 4.0.
Most undocumented e-waste is stored in drawers, thrown in household trash, or handled by informal recyclers.
Informal recycling recovers real value and employs many people. It also exposes workers, often including children, to lead, mercury and the dioxins released by burning cable insulation.
The Basel Convention restricts exports of hazardous waste, but used electronics can be shipped as “secondhand goods,” and the line between the two is hard to enforce.
Design question: what would make a laptop worth more to a formal recycler than to someone with a fire?
Source: Global E-waste Monitor 2024.
2 min. Ghanaian authorities bulldozed the Agbogbloshie scrapyard on 1 July 2021 as part of a city decongestion drive; scrap dealers have since returned to parts of the cleared land, and the site’s redevelopment was still unsettled in 2025.
Critical Minerals: Demand and Concentration
Demand growth to 2040, IEA Stated Policies scenario
Lithium
>3×
Graphite
2×
Nickel
+65%
Rare earths
+50%
Cobalt
+30%
Copper
+25%
Bar length is 2040 demand relative to today.
China’s share of refining, 2025
Battery-grade graphite
>90%
Rare earth magnet elements
85%
Cobalt
75%
Lithium
70%
Copper
~50%
Mining is concentrated too: the DR Congo mines 66% of the world’s cobalt and Indonesia almost two-thirds of its nickel.
An electric car needs about six times the mineral inputs of a conventional car.
Sources: IEA, Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026; IEA (2021), The Role of Critical Minerals in Clean Energy Transitions.
3 min. The 2026 Outlook dropped the net-zero scenario; its scenarios are Current Policies, Stated Policies and High Demand. Under faster deployment the growth multiples are larger. Refining is more concentrated than mining: lithium is mined mostly in Australia, Chile and Argentina but refined mostly in China.
The Mining Behind the Transition
Lithium brine evaporation ponds, Salar de Atacama, Chile, from the International Space Station, 2020. Photo: NASA, public domain.Artisanal cobalt miners, DR Congo. Photo: IIED, CC BY 2.5.Bingham Canyon copper mine, Utah, 2012. Photo: David Ratledge, CC BY 4.0.
Lithium brine
Brine is pumped from under the salt flat and evaporated in ponds, in one of the driest places on Earth. In 2019 a Chilean environmental court sided with Atacameño communities who said SQM was overpumping brine.
Cobalt
Hand-dug artisanal mines, where child labor is documented, produced 40–53% of DRC cobalt around 2008. Industrial mines have since grown, and the artisanal share was about 2% in 2024.
Copper
Wiring, motors, transformers and grid lines. The IEA expects demand to grow more than 25% by 2040.
2 min. Sources: Gulley (2023), PNAS, on artisanal cobalt; Cobalt Institute, citing Benchmark Mineral Intelligence, for the 2024 share; Reuters (Dec 2019) on the SQM ruling. Ask: does mining for clean energy count against it? The useful comparison is with the fossil fuel extraction it replaces, which is billions of tonnes a year (Tuesday’s chart).
Recycling Batteries
EU Battery Regulation (2023/1542)
Requirement
2027
2031
Lithium recovered from waste batteries
50%
80%
Cobalt, copper, nickel, lead recovered
90%
95%
Recycled content in new batteries
2031
2036
Cobalt
16%
26%
Lithium
6%
12%
Nickel
6%
15%
The industry so far
Redwood Materials, Nevada
Founded by a Tesla cofounder, JB Straubel. Says it recovers more than 95% of the critical minerals in the batteries it takes and processed more than 20 GWh of batteries in 2024 (company figures).
Li-Cycle
Once a leading North American recycler; filed for creditor protection in May 2025 and was sold to Glencore for about $46 million.
Sources: IEA Policies database, EU Sustainable Batteries Regulation; Redwood Materials; Torys LLP (2025) on the Li-Cycle sale.
1 min. Redwood was founded by JB Straubel, Tesla’s former chief technology officer.
Part 6
Designing for Circularity
Disassembly, repair, service models and symbiosis
Planned Obsolescence
Built to be replaced
The Phoebus cartel, 1924–25
The major lightbulb makers capped household bulb life at 1,000 hours, down from the 1,500–2,000 hours common before, and sent factory samples to a lab in Switzerland to enforce it. Today’s ENERGY STAR LEDs are rated about 25 times as long and use at least 75% less energy.
Appliances and phones
Hickel cites the UK appliance trade body: average lifespans fell from over 10 years to under 7. About 13 billion smartphones were sold from 2010 to 2019; about 3 billion are in use.
Perceived obsolescence
Advertising makes working products feel out of date. Americans buy about five times as many garments a year as in 1980.
Hickel’s policy menu
Mandatory warranties set to the longest feasible life of the product.
Right to repair, with affordable parts for owners and independent shops (two slides on).
Leasing, with the maker responsible for repairs and upgrades (product-as-a-service, below).
Limits on advertising: spending caps, no manipulative targeting, ad-free public space, as in São Paulo.
If washing machines and phones lasted four times longer, we would need 75% fewer of them.
Sources: Krajewski (2014), The Great Lightbulb Conspiracy, IEEE Spectrum; Hickel (2020), Less is More, ch. 5, steps 1–2, citing the Whitegoods Trade Association, Statista and Cline (2014), The Atlantic; US DOE Energy Saver, LED lighting.
3 min. The cartel is documented from its own records (Krajewski). The LED comparison is a 25,000-hour rated life against a typical 1,000-hour incandescent. The appliance, phone and clothing figures are Hickel’s secondary citations; present them as his. He puts the responsibility on the system and calls buyers “victims of this machine.” Ask: what is the first thing that failed on a device you replaced, and was it the part or the design?
Design for Disassembly
The European Commission estimates that up to 80% of a product’s environmental impact is set at the design stage.
Rules of thumb
Fasteners over adhesives: screws and clips can be undone; glue and welds usually cannot.
Standard tools and parts: no proprietary screws, no parts locked to one serial number.
One material per part, labeled, so a recycler knows what it is.
Wear parts easy to reach: battery, screen, charging port.
Modules: a broken camera means a new camera module.
Since June 2025, phones sold in the EU must have spare parts available for 7 years after sales end, and batteries that keep 80% capacity after 800 cycles.
Fairphone 3 modules. Each can be replaced with a standard screwdriver. Photo: PKFP, CC BY-SA 4.0.
Sources: European Commission (2012), Ecodesign Your Future; Circular Economy Action Plan COM(2020) 98; EU Regulation 2023/1670 on smartphones and tablets.
3 min. The 80% figure is an EU estimate repeated in policy documents; the original brochure cites no study, so present it as the Commission’s figure. If you have an old phone or laptop handy, ask students how they would get the battery out.
Right to Repair: Colorado Went First
Colorado laws
Law
Covers
In force
HB22-1031
Powered wheelchairs (first in the US)
Jan 2023
HB23-1011
Farm equipment (first in the US)
Jan 2024
HB24-1121
Consumer electronics, incl. limits on parts pairing
Jan 2026
Manufacturers must provide parts, tools, manuals and diagnostic software to owners and independent shops.
Elsewhere
EU Right to Repair Directive (2024/1799)
Applies from July 2026. Manufacturers must offer repair at a reasonable price for covered products, may not block repair with software or design tricks, and choosing repair under warranty adds a year to the warranty.
FTC and states vs. Deere (July 2026)
Settlement requiring Deere to give farmers and independent mechanics access to repair tools and software.
Sources: Colorado General Assembly bill pages; European Commission, Directive on repair of goods; FTC press release, 8 July 2026.
3 min. "Parts pairing" is software that rejects a replacement part, even a genuine one, unless the manufacturer authorizes it. The electronics law excludes cars, game consoles and most medical devices. The farm law repeals itself if Congress passes a federal one. The Deere settlement was awaiting court entry when these slides were made.
Selling the Service, Not the Product
If the maker keeps ownership, a product that lasts longer and uses less energy makes the maker more money.
Light as a service: Schiphol Airport
Since 2015 Philips (now Signify) has owned the light fixtures in Schiphol’s terminals; the airport pays for the light it uses. The system uses 50% less electricity, and the fixtures last 75% longer; Philips takes back and reuses or recycles them.
Tires by the kilometer: Michelin
Truck fleets pay Michelin per kilometer driven, including servicing, instead of buying tires. Michelin profits from tires that last and can be retreaded.
Other examples to think about: carpet tiles leased and taken back, tool libraries, bike and scooter share, cloud computing instead of owned servers. Where can the incentive go wrong?
Sources: Philips press release, 16 April 2015; Tyrepress (2012), Carlsberg UK renews Michelin pay-per-km contract.
2 min. Where it goes wrong: if the user no longer pays per use, they may use more (the service may be priced flat), and scooter shares have had short vehicle lives. That leads into the rebound slide.
Industrial Symbiosis: Kalundborg, Denmark
Since 1972, companies in this Danish town have traded steam, water, heat and byproducts. Today 17 public and private partners exchange more than 20 streams.
Asnæs power station, Kalundborg. Photo: Bob Collowan, CC BY-SA 3.0.
The exchanges grew one deal at a time, each because it saved the partners money; there was no master plan.
1 min. The gypsum exchange (power plant scrubber gypsum to the Gyproc wallboard plant) is historical: Ørsted converted Asnæs from coal to wood chips in 2019–2020, partly funded by a 20-year deal with Novo Nordisk, Novozymes and the town utility, and coal flue gas was the gypsum source. Ask what happens to the symbiosis when one partner closes or changes fuel: the dependencies run both ways.
Repair Is Coming Back
~3,800
Repair Cafés worldwide, from one in Amsterdam in 2009
2021
France starts printing a repairability score on phones, laptops, TVs, washers and mowers
What is changing
Volunteer repair events have spread to every continent; people bring broken lamps, toasters and clothes, and learn to fix them.
Labels make durability visible at the point of sale, so it becomes something makers compete on.
Where you come in
Engineers choose screws over glue and standard parts over proprietary ones.
Students run repair events; Eco-Cycle’s CHaRM in Boulder takes what cannot be fixed.
Hickel’s warranties, repair rights and leasing all exist somewhere already.
Sources: Repair Café International Foundation (count as of late 2025); French anti-waste law (AGEC), repairability index decree.
2 min. The count varies by source (about 3,800 listed in late 2025; the foundation’s director has said over 4,000). France replaced the repairability index with a broader durability index for some products from 2024. Ask whether anyone has been to a repair event, and what broke.
The Circular Economy Rebound
Circular activities can increase total production, which can partly or fully cancel their benefit.
A refurbished phone only saves emissions if it replaces a new phone that would otherwise have been made. If it goes to someone who would not have bought a phone, or lets its first owner upgrade sooner, total production rises.
One smartphone study found refurbished phones need to displace about 60% of new phone sales just to break even on greenhouse gases.
Two mechanisms
Imperfect substitution
Recycled plastic or a used product is not always accepted as a replacement for new, so it adds to supply.
Price effects
Cheaper secondhand goods lower prices and raise total consumption.
Same mechanism as Tuesday’s steam engines (Jevons). The R-ladder’s top rungs (refuse, rethink, reduce) are the ones it does not undo.
Sources: Zink & Geyer (2017), Circular economy rebound, J. Industrial Ecology 21:593; Zink et al. (2014), Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 19:1099.
2 min. The 59.5% break-even is from Zink et al. 2014 (refurbished smartphones vs. new ones) for one set of assumptions; treat it as an illustration of the method. The next slide is Hickel’s alternative.
A Different Answer: Degrowth
Hickel defines degrowth as “a planned downscaling of energy and resource use” in high-income countries, done safely, justly and equitably. Low-income countries, he argues, need to use more.
Cap total resource and energy use and lower the cap each year; charge a fee and return it to everyone as an equal dividend.
Shorter working week and a job guarantee, so fewer products does not mean fewer jobs.
Public services (transit, health care, housing) so people need less income to live well.
Which of these could Boulder do, and which need national law? Who loses income, and does Hickel’s answer convince you?
Source: Hickel (2020), Less is More, intro and ch. 5.
3 min. Hickel separates degrowth from recession: a recession is a growth-dependent economy failing to grow. He says degrowth is about throughput, not GDP; GDP may fall and he accepts that. Step 1 and step 3 are already on today’s slides (repair laws, product-as-a-service), and step 4 was last week. Hickel cites an older estimate of up to 50% food waste (IMechE 2013); the slide uses last week’s FAO and UNEP figures instead. His test for green growth advocates is a falling cap on resource use: if absolute decoupling is possible, the cap should not hurt growth. Bring back Tuesday’s callout question (growing vs. needing less).
Boulder and CU
Eco-Cycle (founded 1976)
Boulder recycling nonprofit; it operates the Center for Hard-to-Recycle Materials (CHaRM) at 6400 Arapahoe Rd.
CHaRM takes what the cart can’t
Electronics, plastic bags and film, block foam, large #2 and #5 plastics, mattresses, scrap metal, bikes, books, cables, even solar panels.
Universal Zero Waste Ordinance (2015)
Every property in Boulder, including businesses and apartments, must provide separate trash, recycling and compost.
56%
City of Boulder diversion, 2024
85%
City goal (originally for 2025)
~50%
CU Boulder campus diversion
Boulder’s rate is far above Colorado’s 15.7%, and still short of the 85% goal it set for 2025.
Sources: Eco-Cycle; City of Boulder, Zero waste diversion; BioCycle (2025); CU Boulder Sustainability.
1 min. CU’s most recent dated figure is 45.6% in fiscal 2021; the sustainability page currently says 50% without a year. Diversion counts recycling and compost by weight, so heavy materials (yard waste, concrete) move it most.
Where This Can Go
“This is not a book about doom. It is a book about hope.”Jason Hickel, Less is More, introduction
Land recovers
Across 45 sites in Latin America, regrowing tropical forests reached 90% of old-growth biomass in a median of 66 years, and in their first 20 years took up carbon 11 times as fast as old growth.
Less work, revenue held
In the 2022 UK four-day-week trial (61 employers, about 2,900 staff), 56 kept the shorter week afterwards. Revenue held steady. Hickel counts working time as a climate policy.
Good lives, smaller footprints
Hickel’s central evidence: countries such as Costa Rica, Portugal and Japan match or beat US life expectancy on far less income per person, through public health care and education.
Hickel’s picture of success is more free time, better public services, longer-lasting things and regrowing forests. Most of the pieces exist already, scattered across different places. The work is putting them together.
Sources: Poorter et al. (2016), Nature 530:211; Autonomy (2023), The results are in: the UK’s four-day week pilot; Hickel (2020), Less is More, chs. 4–6.
2 min. The 66 years is a median; recovery after 20 years varied about 11-fold between sites and was faster where rainfall was higher. In the four-day-week trial, revenue rose 1.4% on average, weighted by company size; of the five firms that did not continue, two extended their trials. The life-expectancy comparison uses Hickel’s figures (US $59,500 per person and 78.7 years; Costa Rica about 80% less income). Close by asking each student for one piece of this they would want to work on.
Activity · 12 minutes · groups of 3–4
Redesign It to Come Back
Start with a product from Tuesday’s warm-up lists, or take one of these: wireless earbuds, a disposable vape, a fast-fashion T-shirt, a shared e-scooter, a takeout container.
Where does it go now? Use the trash, recycling and CHaRM rules from today.
Climb the R-ladder. What is the highest rung you can reach? What would have to change in the design, the business model, or the law?
Check for burden shifting. Which impact category might get worse? Who pays more?
Check for rebound. Does your redesign make people use more of it?
Each group reports one redesign in 60 seconds.
12 min. 7 min in groups, 5 min report. Earbuds and vapes are good because they have glued lithium batteries (fire risk in trucks, as in the warm-up). Push groups that stop at "make it recyclable" to try R0–R4 first. Policy levers from today: EPR fees, right to repair, EU ecodesign rules, and Hickel’s warranties, ad limits and sharing. Refuse (R0) is where his step 5 sits.
Key Takeaways
The economy is growing its material stock
About 106 billion tonnes a year enter the economy and under 7% is recycled. Much of it is locked in buildings for decades.
Higher loops keep more value
Refuse, rethink, reduce, reuse and repair before recycling. Recycling keeps the atoms; reuse keeps the product.
LCA is how you check
Define the functional unit and the boundary, count more than carbon, and ask who paid.
Materials have chemistry you can’t electrify away
Cement’s limestone and steel’s coke; recycled aluminum and scrap steel show what the circular route saves.
Plastics and e-waste are design and policy problems
Design and policy can fix them. Producer responsibility and repair laws are spreading, and the ozone layer and Ireland’s bag levy show how fast use can change.
Watch for rebound and growth
A circular product only helps if it replaces new production. Hickel argues that while total throughput grows, recycling and efficiency get outrun, and that rich countries can plan to use less and live better.