CU Boulder · EVEN 2909 · Sustainable Buildings & Transportation
← Course Home

Sustainable Buildings & Transportation

EVEN 2909: Introduction to Global Sustainability

University of Colorado Boulder

Keys: S toggles these notes, R reveals answers on quiz slides, Esc opens the slide overview. Thursday starts at the green dots on the right edge (the "Thursday" divider). Budgets in these notes total about 64 minutes on Tuesday and 82 on Thursday.

This Week

Tuesday: buildings

Where building energy goes, nationally and in your own home.
The physics: heat flow, air leakage, and how a heat pump moves heat.
Gas furnace or heat pump on Colorado’s grid: a worked comparison.
Passive House, net-zero buildings, the Marshall Fire rebuild, and building performance laws.

Thursday: transportation

Emissions by mode, and why occupancy matters.
Electric vehicles: sales, life-cycle emissions, and a year of policy reversals.
Land use: induced demand, sprawl, transit and bikes on the Front Range.
Freight, aviation, shipping and urban heat.

Last week covered embodied carbon in materials. This week is mostly about the energy buildings and vehicles use every day.

1 min.
Warm-up · 5 minutes · pairs

Where Does a US Home’s Energy Go?

Rank these uses from largest to smallest share of household energy. Then press reveal.

Lighting2.9%
Refrigerators3.7%
Space heating42.5%
TVs and electronics connected to them2.7%
Air conditioning9.1%
Water heating18.3%
Cooking2.4%

Heating air and water is 61% of the energy used in US homes. The items people usually rank first (lights, TVs, the fridge) add up to under 10%.

Source: EIA, Residential Energy Consumption Survey 2020, Tables CE3.1 and CE5.1–5.2 (share of site energy).

5 min. These are site energy shares (energy delivered to the home). Counting power-plant losses would raise the electric uses. The remaining 26% is "other": dryers, dishwashers, pool pumps, computers, small appliances. Ask what is different for a CU dorm room: heating and hot water come from the central plant, so students rarely see those bills.
Part 1

Where Building Energy Goes

The national picture, your home, and the stock we already have

Buildings Use More Than a Third of US Energy

Share of US primary energy, 2024 (including power-plant losses)

Industrial
33.2%
Transportation
29.9%
Residential
19.4%
Commercial
17.4%

Homes and commercial buildings together: 36.8%.

Share of US greenhouse gases, 2023

SectorBurned on siteIncl. electricity used
Commercial7.3%15.6%
Residential5.9%14.4%
Buildings13.2%30.0%
Transportation29.4%29.5%

Most building emissions happen at a power plant, so a building’s footprint depends on the grid that serves it.

Sources: EIA, Monthly Energy Review, Tables 1.1, 2.1 (2024); EPA, Inventory of US GHG Emissions and Sinks 1990–2023, Tables ES-5 and ES-6.

3 min. EPA did not publish the 1990–2023 inventory; the final report was released by the Environmental Defense Fund through a FOIA request in 2025. It is EPA’s own analysis. Preliminary 2025 EIA data show buildings at 37.8%. Globally, building operations are about 26% of energy-related CO2 (GlobalABC 2025–2026, from last week).

Heat Is Most of the Bill, Especially in Colorado

US household energy by end use, 2020

Space heating
42.5%
Water heating
18.3%
Air conditioning
9.1%
Refrigerators
3.7%
Everything else
26.4%
76%
Of Colorado homes heat mainly with natural gas
5,511
Heating degree days a year in Boulder

Nationally, 51% of homes heat with gas, 34% with electricity, and 13% with a heat pump as the main system.

Homes in the Mountain North region use about 45.6 million Btu a year for space heating, a third more than the US average of 34.4.

Sources: EIA RECS 2020, Tables CE3.1, HC6.1 and state space-heating fuels; NOAA 1991–2020 climate normals, Boulder station (base 65 °F).

3 min. A heating degree day is one day with the average temperature one degree below 65 °F. Boulder’s 5,511 means a house needs heat on most days from October to April. Denver International Airport is 5,862. Mountain North is EIA’s division containing Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Utah and Wyoming.

The Buildings of 2050 Are Mostly Here

52%
Of US homes built before 1980
~½
Of today’s buildings in advanced economies still standing in 2050

New buildings can be designed to near zero. The larger job is the existing stock: sealing, insulating and electrifying buildings while people live and work in them.

A weatherization crew member installing insulation and a moisture barrier in a crawl space
A DOE Weatherization Assistance Program crew insulating a crawl space in Lakewood, Colorado. Photo: US Department of Energy, public domain.

Sources: EIA RECS 2020, Table HC2.1; IEA (2021), Net Zero by 2050, section 3.7.1.

2 min. The IEA statement is for advanced economies generally. You will see "80% of 2050 buildings already exist" quoted widely; I could not find it in a primary source, so it is left off.
Part 2

The Physics of Building Energy

Heat flow, air leakage, and heat pumps

Heat Flows From Warm to Cold

Q = U × A × ΔT

  • Q: heat flow through a wall, window or roof (Btu per hour)
  • U: how easily heat passes through it (Btu/hr·ft²·°F). Insulation is rated by R = 1/U.
  • A: area (ft²)
  • ΔT: inside minus outside temperature (°F)

Over a whole season, replace ΔT with heating degree days × 24 hours:

Annual heat loss = U × A × HDD × 24

Heat also leaves with air: every cubic foot of warm air that leaks out is replaced by cold air that must be heated.

A house shown half as a normal photo and half as an infrared image, with windows and parts of the wall glowing where heat escapes
The same house in visible light (right) and infrared (left). Windows and thin spots in the wall glow. Photo: Explorer1001, CC BY-SA 3.0.
3 min. Infrared cameras are what energy auditors use to find missing insulation. Many hardware stores and libraries lend them.
Worked example · 4 minutes

One Wall of Windows in Boulder

A house has 100 ft² of windows. Boulder has 5,511 heating degree days. Use these values for the window U-factor:

  • Old single-pane window: U = 1.1
  • Modern triple-pane window: U = 0.2

How much heat (million Btu) leaves through the windows each heating season? How much gas does a 95%-efficient furnace burn to replace it, and how much CO2 is that? (Natural gas: 53.06 kg CO2 per million Btu.)

WindowHeat lost · CO2
Single pane: 1.1 × 100 × 5,511 × 2414.5 MMBtu · 810 kg
Triple pane: 0.2 × 100 × 5,511 × 242.6 MMBtu · 150 kg

CO2 = heat lost ÷ 0.95 × 53.06. Same window area, about 660 kg of CO2 a year apart.

Emission factor: EPA, GHG Emission Factors Hub 2025, Table 1. Degree days: NOAA 1991–2020 normals. U-values are given for the exercise.

4 min. Work it on the board: 1.1 × 100 × 5,511 × 24 = 14,549,040 Btu = 14.5 MMBtu; ÷ 0.95 = 15.3 MMBtu of gas; × 53.06 = 813 kg. Triple pane: 2,645,280 Btu = 2.65 MMBtu; ÷ 0.95 × 53.06 = 148 kg. Ask what this ignores: solar heat coming in through the glass, and air leaking around the frame.

Seal the Leaks, Then Insulate

25–40%
Of heating & cooling energy lost to air leakage in a typical home
~15%
Average heating & cooling savings from sealing + attic insulation

A blower door fan depressurizes the house to 50 pascals and measures how much air it takes to hold that pressure. The result, air changes per hour at 50 Pa (ACH50), is how airtightness is specified.

Auditors walk the house with the fan running to find leaks: attic hatches, plumbing and wiring holes, recessed lights, the rim joist above the foundation.

Sealing comes before insulation because air moving through insulation carries the heat around it.

A red blower door frame with a fan and pressure gauge fitted into a front doorway
Blower door test. Photo: Still life with noodles, CC BY-SA 4.0.
A worker installing insulation batts in an attic
Installing attic insulation. Photo: The EnergySmart Academy, CC0.

Sources: ENERGY STAR, Air Sealing: Building Envelope Improvements (EPA/DOE fact sheet); ENERGY STAR, Seal and Insulate methodology (savings range 5–16% by climate zone).

3 min. The 15% is modeled, for a 25% cut in air leakage plus insulation brought up to the 2012 IECC; ENERGY STAR gives 11% of total energy costs. The 25–40% figure is from an older ENERGY STAR fact sheet; DOE’s current page gives no percentage.

A Heat Pump Moves Heat Instead of Making It

OUTDOORS (cold) INDOORS (warm) wall Outdoor coilrefrigerant evaporates Indoor coilrefrigerant condenses Compressoruses electricity Expansion valvepressure drops low-pressure gas hot high-pressure gas warm liquid cold liquid heat from outside air heat into the house

A refrigerant absorbs heat outdoors as it evaporates, a compressor raises its pressure and temperature, and it releases that heat indoors as it condenses. Reverse the flow and the same machine is an air conditioner.

Coefficient of performance (COP) = heat delivered ÷ electricity used. A furnace or electric heater can never exceed 1. A heat pump typically delivers 3 to 5.

COP falls as the outdoor air gets colder. A heat pump sold as “cold-climate” must still reach a COP of at least 1.75 at 5 °F.

A heat pump outdoor unit running in falling snow with frost on its coil
Outdoor unit running in snow. Photo: PeterEastern, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Sources: IEA (2022), The Future of Heat Pumps; NEEP, Cold Climate Air Source Heat Pump Specification v4.0 (2023).

3 min. Your refrigerator is a heat pump: feel the back of it. IEA says heat pumps are three to five times more efficient than gas boilers. The frost on the coil in the photo is why outdoor units run short defrost cycles in winter.
Quiz · 6 minutes · pairs

Gas Furnace or Heat Pump on Colorado’s Grid?

Deliver 1 million Btu of heat to a Boulder home (293 kWh). Colorado’s grid emitted 958 lb (434 kg) of CO2 per MWh in 2024. Gas: 53.06 kg CO2 per million Btu. Which option emits least? Guess first, then calculate one row each.

Optionkg CO2
Gas furnace, 95% efficient55.9
Electric baseboard heat (COP 1)127.4
Heat pump, mild winter day (COP 3)42.4
Cold-climate heat pump at 5 °F (COP 1.75)72.8

At COP 3 the heat pump wins on any grid cleaner than about 1,260 lb/MWh. At COP 1.75 the grid has to be cleaner than about 735 lb/MWh. Colorado’s law requires Xcel to cut power-sector CO2 80% below 2005 by 2030, which moves every row except the furnace.

Sources: EIA, Colorado State Electricity Profile 2024; EPA GHG Emission Factors Hub 2025; C.R.S. 40-2-125.5.

6 min. Furnace: 1 ÷ 0.95 × 53.06 = 55.9 kg. Baseboard: 293 kWh × 0.434 = 127.4 kg. COP 3: 97.7 kWh × 0.434 = 42.4 kg. COP 1.75: 167.5 kWh × 0.434 = 72.8 kg. What is left out: methane leaking from gas wells and pipelines (which favors the heat pump), and the fact that the marginal power plant on a cold night may be dirtier than the average (EPA eGRID’s non-baseload rate for the Rockies is 1,621 lb/MWh). Over a whole season most hours are milder than 5 °F, so the seasonal COP is what matters. Boulder Reporting Lab (Aug 2026) reported Xcel missed its 2022 and 2024 interim reduction benchmarks but projects 90% by 2030.

Heat Pumps in the Market

US shipments (units)

20242025
Air-source heat pumps4.12 M3.64 M
Gas furnaces3.12 M3.25 M

Heat pumps have outsold gas furnaces in the US, but the gap narrowed in 2025.

An air-source heat pump unit on the ground beside a brick terraced house
A retrofit heat pump beside a terraced house. Photo: Southend-on-Sea Borough Council, CC0.

Global

Global heat pump sales fell about 2% in 2025, after small declines in 2023 and 2024. European sales rose 11%, the first growth since 2022; US sales fell about 13%.

What changed in the US in 2025

The July 2025 budget law ended the federal tax credits for home efficiency upgrades and heat pumps (25C) and for rooftop solar (25D) after December 31, 2025. The credit for efficient new homes (45L) ended June 30, 2026.

Colorado’s federally funded home electrification rebates for single-family homes took applications from November 2025 to August 2026 and are closed.

Sources: AHRI year-end shipment data via Contracting Business (2026); IEA, Global Energy Review 2026; IRS Fact Sheet FS-2025-05; Colorado Energy Office, Home Energy Rebates (Oct 2026).

2 min. The budget law is Public Law 119-21 (the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act"). Check the Colorado Energy Office and Xcel pages for current state and utility incentives before class; they change often.
Part 3

Designing and Regulating Better Buildings

From Passive House to the Marshall Fire rebuild

Passive House: Reduce First

The Passive House standard, developed in Germany, sets limits on what the building itself may need, before any equipment or solar panels.

CriterionLimit
Space heating demand≤ 15 kWh/m² per year
Airtightness≤ 0.6 ACH50
Renewable primary energy (Classic)≤ 60 kWh/m² per year

To get there: thick continuous insulation, triple-pane windows, no thermal bridges, very tight construction, and ventilation that recovers heat from the outgoing air.

A row of terraced houses with large south-facing windows and green surroundings
Darmstadt-Kranichstein, Germany (1991), the first Passive House building. Photo: Passivhaus Institut, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Source: Passive House Institute, Criteria for Buildings, v10c (2023), Table 1.

2 min. For scale: 15 kWh/m² is about 1.4 kWh/ft², or 4,800 Btu/ft² a year.

Net Zero on the Front Range

The long south facade of the NREL Research Support Facility with rows of windows and exterior shades
NREL’s Research Support Facility, Golden, Colorado. Photo: Bill Gillies, NREL.

NREL Research Support Facility, Golden (2010)

A 222,000 ft² office designed to produce as much energy as it uses over a year. In its first year it used 35.4 thousand Btu per ft², including a full data center, close to its 35.1 target. It cost about $259 per ft² to build, against $247 for a nearby LEED Platinum office.

Boulder’s 2024 energy code

Since December 2024, new homes in Boulder must be all-electric. New homes of 3,000 ft² or more must be net-zero energy; smaller ones must reach an Energy Rating Index of 30 or lower, counting solar. All-electric commercial buildings must beat the ASHRAE 90.1-2022 baseline by 10%.

Reduce, then produce: design daylighting, shading and envelope first, then size the solar to what is left.

Sources: ENR (16 Apr 2012); Green Building News (10 Sep 2010); City of Boulder, 2024 Energy Conservation Code FAQ.

3 min. The RSF was later expanded to about 360,000 ft² with a third wing. A lower ERI is better: 100 is a home built to the 2006 code, 0 is net zero. Ask whether a 3,000 ft² net-zero house is better or worse for the climate than a 1,500 ft² house that is not.

Whole-Life Carbon: Embodied Plus Operational

Years since construction → 60 Cumulative emissions embodied: emitted before move-in Conventional building Efficient, all-electric, cleaning grid Schematic, not to scale

A building’s embodied carbon is emitted before anyone moves in. Its operational carbon accumulates every year it runs.

An efficient, all-electric building on a cleaning grid has a flatter operational line, so the up-front embodied carbon becomes a larger share of its lifetime total.

That is why reusing an existing building, or building with less concrete and steel, matters more as the grid gets cleaner.

Schematic, not to scale. See last week’s embodied carbon slides for material figures.

2 min. Callback to the circular economy deck: embodied carbon of new construction to 2050 is roughly half of new-construction emissions (Architecture 2030). Ask where the two lines cross and what would move that point earlier or later.

Rebuilding After the Marshall Fire

Aerial view of a neighborhood with burned-out lots next to surviving houses
Burned lots beside surviving homes, Boulder County, 7 January 2022. Photo: Adam Schultz, White House, public domain.

The fire on December 30, 2021 destroyed 1,084 homes in Louisville, Superior and unincorporated Boulder County.

Louisville and Superior had just adopted the 2021 energy code. To ease the cost for fire victims, both let them rebuild to the older 2018 code; those homes did not qualify for state and Xcel efficiency rebates.

By October 2022, 41% of permitted rebuilds were going to the higher, rebate-qualifying standards. By the end of 2025 about 800 homes had been fully rebuilt.

A rebuild locks in its envelope and heating system for decades. Who should pay the extra cost of building it efficient: the owner, the town, the utility, or the insurer?

Sources: Boulder County damage assessment (Jan 2022), via Colorado Newsline; Louisville ordinance (Apr 2022); Boulder County (Oct 2022); Denver7 (Dec 2025).

3 min. Some later counts give 1,105 or more homes. Loss estimate: $513 million. Louisville reported in August 2026 that 532 of its 550 destroyed homes had been rebuilt or were under construction.

Building Performance Laws

Colorado (HB21-1286)

Commercial buildings of 50,000 ft² and up must report energy use every year. Sector goal: cut emissions 7% by 2026 and 20% by 2030 versus 2021. A 2025 law (HB25-1269) adds 2040 standards and penalties of up to $2,300 per 30 days from 2030.

Energize Denver

Buildings of 25,000 ft² and up. In April 2025 Denver pushed its interim and final targets to 2028 and 2032, halved penalties, and capped required energy cuts at 42%.

Boulder

Commercial buildings of 20,000 ft² and up must report, audit every 10 years, upgrade lighting and retro-commission. SmartRegs requires every licensed rental to meet a minimum efficiency standard (HERS 120 or a 100-point checklist).

Performance standards regulate measured results, not design. A building owner chooses how to get there: tune-ups, retrofits, electrification, or paying the penalty.

Sources: Colorado Energy Office, Building Performance Colorado (2026); Facilities Dive (9 Apr 2025); City of Boulder, Building Performance Ordinance and SmartRegs pages.

2 min. Boulder is considering (2026–27) replacing its rules for buildings of 50,000 ft² and up with performance targets aligned to the state’s; not yet adopted.

Who Pays, and Who Benefits?

2.9%
Median US household energy burden
8.3%
Median for low-income households
15.2%
Burden of the worst-off quarter of low-income households

Energy burden is the share of income spent on home energy. A heating bill of the same size takes three times the share of a low-income household’s budget as of a median one.

The split incentive

In a rental, the landlord pays for insulation or a heat pump, and the tenant gets the lower bill. Neither has a reason to act alone. SmartRegs is one answer: make efficiency a condition of the rental license.

Source: ACEEE (2024), Data Update: City Energy Burdens, from the American Housing Survey.

2 min. Ask how many students rent, how many have ever seen their building’s energy rating, and who pays for heat.
Activity · 12 minutes · groups of 3–4

Retrofit a Boulder Rental

A 1972 duplex near campus: gas furnace and gas water heater, single-pane windows, little attic insulation, four student tenants who pay the utilities. The owner has $20,000 to spend this year.

Choose and order your upgrades:

  • Air sealing and attic insulation
  • New windows
  • Cold-climate heat pump (keep or remove the furnace)
  • Heat pump water heater
  • Rooftop solar
  • Smart thermostats

Write down:

  1. Your first three upgrades, in order, and why that order.
  2. Which ones cut CO2 most on today’s grid, and which on the 2030 grid.
  3. How the tenants and the owner each come out.
  4. One thing you would need to measure before deciding.
12 min. 8 min in groups, 4 min report. Prices are deliberately left out: groups should name what they would need to look up. Good answers seal and insulate first (cheapest, and it shrinks the heat pump you need), and use the quiz slide to argue about keeping the furnace as cold-day backup. Push on the split incentive: who signs up for solar if the tenants pay the bill?
Exit ticket · 3 minutes

Before You Leave

  1. What is the biggest energy use in the place you live, and who pays for it?
  2. On what kind of day can a gas furnace emit less than a heat pump in Colorado today?
  3. One question about buildings you want answered Thursday.

Thursday: transportation. Before class, note how you got to campus each day this week.

3 min.
Thursday

Moving People and Goods

Vehicles, land use, and the largest source of US emissions

1 min. Recap Tuesday: building emissions are mostly heat, and whether electrifying it helps depends on the grid and on the coldest days.
Warm-up · 5 minutes

How Did You Get Here?

Show of hands for your main mode this week: walk, bike or e-bike, scooter, bus, drove alone, carpool. Then guess the shares for people who work in Boulder.

Boulder Valley employees, primary commute mode (2025)Share
Drive alone66%
Bike10%
Transit2%

Boulder residents drive alone for 35% of all their trips (2023), down from 44% in 1990. People who commute into Boulder from elsewhere drove alone for 80% of work trips (2022).

Sources: City of Boulder, 2025 Boulder Valley Employee Survey (Mar 2026); City of Boulder, 2025 Transportation Report on Progress.

5 min. Tally the room on the board and compare. Every tuition-paying CU student can ride RTD fare-free with a Buff OneCard; ask how many knew. Ask why people commuting in from outside Boulder drive alone so much more than residents.
Part 4

Transportation Emissions

Which vehicles, and how full they are

Transportation Is the Largest US Source

29.4%
Of US greenhouse gases, 2023
~24%
Of global energy-related CO2, 2024

Light-duty vehicles, the cars, SUVs and pickups most people drive, are over half of it.

Globally, road vehicles emitted just over 6 billion tonnes of CO2 in 2024, and passenger cars and vans were over 60% of that.

US transportation emissions by source, 2023

Light-duty trucks (SUVs, pickups, vans)
39.7%
Medium & heavy trucks
23.4%
Passenger cars
16.6%
Commercial aircraft
7.2%
Pipelines
3.9%
Other aircraft
2.8%
Ships and boats
2.4%
Rail
1.9%

Sources: EPA, Inventory of US GHG Emissions and Sinks 1990–2023, Executive Summary and Ch. 2 (released via FOIA, 2025); IEA CO2 emissions by sector (2024); IEA, Breakthrough Agenda Report 2025.

3 min. "Light-duty trucks" is the EPA category for SUVs, pickups and minivans; it has grown as buyers moved out of sedans. The global share is transport’s share of fuel-combustion CO2 in IEA data (8.5 of 35.5 Gt).

Emissions per Passenger-Kilometer, by Mode

Grams CO2e per passenger-km (UK factors, 2022)

Domestic flight
246
Gasoline car, driver only
170
Short-haul flight
151
Long-haul flight
148
Motorbike
114
Bus (UK average)
97
Plug-in hybrid, driver only
68
Electric car, driver only
47
National rail
35
Tram / light rail
29
Intercity coach
27
Walk or bike
~0

Two people in a gasoline car halve its per-person number. A full coach beats a nearly empty city bus.

Flights include the extra warming from emissions at altitude. Car factors are per vehicle, so they assume one person in it.

The electric car’s number depends on the grid charging it; this one is for the UK grid, which is cleaner than Colorado’s.

Source: UK DESNZ, Greenhouse gas reporting conversion factors 2022, via Our World in Data. Walking and cycling are direct emissions only.

3 min. The UK factors are used because they are consistent across modes in one dataset. The next slide uses US energy data, which tells a different story about buses.

In the US, Occupancy Changes the Ranking

Energy per passenger-mile, US, 2023 (Btu)

Transit bus
5,612
Light trucks
3,364
Cars
2,914
Commuter rail
2,566
Airlines
2,364
Amtrak
1,556
Rail transit (subway, light rail)
1,127

The average US transit bus carries about 6 people, so per passenger it uses more energy than a car carrying 1.5.

A bus is efficient when it is full. Ridership depends on frequency, where people live and work, and how easy it is to drive and park instead.

Airliners average about 129 passengers per flight, which is why flying looks efficient per mile here. It is the distance flown that makes flying a large footprint.

Source: Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Transportation Energy Data Book, Edition 41 (2025), Tables 2.13–2.15. Table 2.13 gives cars 2,795 Btu; the two tables differ.

3 min. Household vehicle occupancy was 1.4 in 2022, the lowest in the NHTS series. Ask: what would have to change for the bus line to be full? This sets up the land use section.
Part 5

Electrifying Vehicles

Sales, life-cycle emissions, and policy

One in Four New Cars Sold Worldwide Is Electric

20M+
Electric cars sold, 2025 (25% of sales)
$108
Average battery pack price per kWh, 2025

China sold over 13 million (almost 55% of its sales). Europe 28%. The US about 1.5 million, around 10%.

Sources: IEA, Global EV Outlook 2026; BloombergNEF battery price survey (Dec 2025); chart via Our World in Data.

3 min. "Electric" includes plug-in hybrids. BEV-only battery packs averaged $99/kWh in 2025. Hover the chart to compare countries; Norway is near 100%.

Life-Cycle Emissions, Battery Included

US, grams CO2e per km over the vehicle’s life

Gasoline car
254
Battery-electric car
83–103
Gasoline SUV
312
Battery-electric SUV
105–133

The range reflects ICCT’s scenarios for how the grid changes over the car’s life. Bars show the upper value.

An electric car starts life with higher emissions, because making the battery is energy-intensive. It makes up the difference through lower emissions for every kilometer driven.

Over its whole life, a medium-size battery-electric car registered in the US in 2021 emits 60–68% less than a comparable gasoline car.

This is the functional unit lesson from last week: compare per kilometer over a lifetime, not per car at the factory gate.

Source: Bieker (2021), A Global Comparison of the Life-Cycle Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Combustion Engine and Electric Passenger Cars, ICCT, US chapter.

3 min. ICCT’s 2025 European update found battery-electric cars 73% lower and put the payback at about 17,000 km; I could only see that in summaries, so it is not on the slide. Ask what would close the remaining gap: a cleaner grid and smaller vehicles.

A Year of US Policy Reversals

Federal

  • Sept 30, 2025: the federal tax credits for new and used EVs ended, under the July 2025 budget law.
  • June 2025: Congress used the Congressional Review Act to revoke California’s waivers for its vehicle emission rules; states have sued.
  • Feb 12, 2026: EPA rescinded its 2009 finding that greenhouse gases endanger public health, and with it the vehicle GHG standards. The rescission is being challenged in federal court.

Colorado

32.4%
Of new vehicles sold in Colorado were EVs, Q3 2025, a record for any state
  • State EV tax credit: $6,000 on cheaper cars in 2025, $3,250 in 2026, rising again in 2027.
  • Colorado adopted California’s Advanced Clean Cars II rule (82% of new cars zero-emission by model year 2032); how it can be enforced after the waiver revocation is uncertain.

Sources: IRS, Clean vehicle tax credits; Colorado Energy Office (22 Oct 2025 press release; EV tax credit page); CDOT (Jul 2025), GHG planning standard report, p. 24; court filings in APHA v. EPA, No. 26-1037 (D.C. Cir.).

3 min. Colorado 2026 credit: $750 base plus $2,500 for vehicles with MSRP up to $35,000. In 2027: $2,000 base for MSRP up to $50,000, add-on under $40,000. The Q3 2025 spike was partly buyers rushing before the federal credit ended. Check the endangerment case status before class.

Charging, Buses and Trucks

DC fast chargers with an electric car plugged in
DC fast chargers. Photo: 4300streetcar, CC BY 4.0.
Several electric transit buses plugged into chargers at a depot
Electric buses charging at an MTA depot, New York. Photo: Marc A. Hermann / MTA, CC BY 2.0.
An electric semi truck pulling a trailer on a highway
A battery-electric semi on a California freeway. Photo: Daniel Lu, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Charging

In DOE’s early EV Project, 84% of charging events were at drivers’ homes. Renters without a garage or driveway depend on public chargers.

Buses

Boulder’s HOP has run electric buses since 2021, added 7 more in 2025, and aims for an all-electric fleet by 2030. RTD canceled a 17-bus order in 2023 because it lacked charging space.

Trucks

Trucks are 23% of US transport emissions. Over 400,000 electric trucks were sold worldwide in 2025, 9% of sales; in the US, 17,000.

Sources: Idaho National Laboratory, EV Project; City of Boulder (2025), HOP route expansion; Metro Magazine (2023); IEA, Global EV Outlook 2026; EPA GHG Inventory 1990–2023.

2 min. The EV Project data are from early adopters (about 2011–2013), who were more likely to own homes with garages. One in four trucks sold in China in 2025 was electric.
Part 6

Land Use: How Far We Have to Go

Roads, sprawl, transit and bikes

Induced Demand

Across US metro areas, vehicle-kilometers traveled on interstates rise roughly one-for-one with lane-kilometers built. Add 10% more lanes, get about 10% more driving.

Katy Freeway, Houston

Widened to as many as 23 lanes at a cost of more than $2.8 billion, finished in 2011. Between 2011 and 2014, morning peak travel time rose 30% and evening peak time 55%.

New capacity makes driving faster at first, so people make trips they used to skip, live farther away, or shift from other times and routes, until the road is congested again.

Heavy traffic on a wide multi-lane freeway
I-405, Los Angeles. Photo: Carol M. Highsmith, Library of Congress, public domain.

Sources: Duranton & Turner (2011), The fundamental law of road congestion, American Economic Review 101:2616; City Observatory (2015), using Houston TranStar data.

3 min. The working paper reports elasticities very close to one. Ask: if widening does not cure congestion, what does? Pricing (tolls, congestion charges) and alternatives. The US 36 express lanes that the Flatiron Flyer uses are tolled.

Where You Live Sets How Much You Drive

Change in driving from a 10% change in each factor

Closer to downtown
−2.2%
More jobs reachable by car
−2.0%
More street intersections
−1.2%
More land-use mix
−0.9%
Closer to a transit stop
−0.5%
Higher residential density
−0.4%

Density alone does little. What cuts driving is having destinations close by: a central location, a connected street grid, and shops and jobs mixed in with housing.

Aerial view of a cul-de-sac subdivision cut into forest
Cul-de-sac subdivision near Atlanta. Few through-streets means long trips to anywhere. Photo: Tony Webster, CC BY 2.0.

Source: Ewing & Cervero (2010), Travel and the built environment: a meta-analysis, J. American Planning Association 76:265, Table 3 (elasticities of vehicle-miles traveled).

3 min. An elasticity of −0.22 for distance to downtown means a 10% shorter distance goes with 2.2% less driving. These are averages across many studies and are associations; people who want to drive less may choose to live centrally. Parking is part of the same story: free parking at both ends makes driving the default.

Transit on the Front Range

An RTD Flatiron Flyer bus in the express lane of US 36
RTD Flatiron Flyer on US 36. Photo: Xnatedawgx, CC BY-SA 4.0.
An RTD A Line commuter train at Denver Union Station
RTD A Line at Denver Union Station. Photo: Xnatedawgx, CC BY-SA 4.0.

CU’s transit pass

Every tuition-paying student rides any regular RTD route fare-free with a Buff OneCard. Since fall 2025 the cost is part of tuition.

Northwest Rail to Boulder

RTD district voters approved a sales tax in 2004 (FasTracks) that included a Denver–Boulder–Longmont rail line; it was never built. RTD’s 2024 study proposed three weekday trips each way, with no start date.

Front Range Passenger Rail

In April 2026 the state reached a tentative deal with BNSF for three daily Denver–Fort Collins round trips, stopping in Boulder and Longmont, targeted for 2029.

Sources: CU Boulder Environmental Center, RTD College Pass; RTD, Northwest Rail Peak Service Study (2024); news reports of the state–BNSF agreement (Apr 2026).

3 min. Boulder County supported FasTracks with 64.4% of the vote. The April 2026 BNSF deal figures (about $330 million, January 2029 target) come from news reports; confirm with the Front Range Passenger Rail District before quoting the date.

Bikes, E-Bikes and Safety

E-bikes replace car trips

Across studies, a median 24% of e-bike trips replace a car trip. In Colorado’s 2025 survey of 3,100 state rebate recipients, a third said they replace 2–3 car trips a week. Denver’s 2022 rebate riders averaged 26 miles a week.

Colorado’s e-bike credit

$450 off at the point of sale since April 2024.

Safety is a transportation outcome

36,640 people died on US roads in 2025, down 6.7% from 2024. Pedestrian deaths were projected at 6,732, the third yearly decline.

People bike where they feel safe: separated lanes, slower traffic, and connected routes.

A crowd of cyclists waiting at a Copenhagen intersection at rush hour
Rush hour, Copenhagen. Photo: heb, CC BY-SA 3.0.
A two-way bike lane separated from traffic by flexible posts
Protected bike lane, Washington DC. Photo: NTSB, public domain.

Sources: Bigazzi & Wong (2020), Transportation Research Part D 85:102412; Colorado Sun (11 Aug 2025); Smart Cities Dive (Mar 2023); NHTSA, DOT HS 813 800 (Apr 2026); GHSA (Jul 2026).

3 min. Bigazzi & Wong also found a median 33% of e-bike trips replace transit trips, which do not cut emissions much. Ask: what would make you bike in January?
Activity · 15 minutes · groups of 3–4

Divide the Street

Parking8 ft Travel11 ft Travel11 ft Travel11 ft Travel11 ft Parking8 ft Today: 8 + 11 + 11 + 11 + 11 + 8 = 60 ft curb to curb

A 60-foot-wide arterial street in Boulder, curb to curb, runs past apartments, a grocery store and a high school. Today it carries four car lanes and two parking lanes. Redesign it. Use these widths:

  • Car travel lane: 10–11 ft
  • Bus-only lane: 11–12 ft
  • Parking lane: 8 ft
  • Protected bike lane (one way): 6–7 ft, plus 3 ft buffer
  • Center turn lane or median: 10–12 ft
  • Wider sidewalk or street trees: take from the street
  • Report: your cross-section, who gains and who loses, what it does to bus speed and safety, and what you would measure after a year.
15 min. 9 min in groups, 6 min report. Hand out paper strips or have them sketch. The widths are typical design values given for the exercise. Push on trade-offs: removing parking upsets the grocery store; a bus lane only helps if buses run often; FHWA counts the road diet (four lanes to two plus a center turn lane) as a proven safety measure, with 19–47% fewer crashes in its evaluations. Connect to induced demand: removing a lane does not always move all its traffic elsewhere.
Part 7 · Case study

Trail Bridges in Rwanda

A randomized trial of first-mile transportation infrastructure, 2020–2024

Full mini-lecture version

1 min. This is our own study, with Wyatt Brooks (Arizona State) and Kevin Donovan (Yale), and Denis Muthike, Lambert Mugabo and Laura MacDonald at the Mortenson Center. The numbers are from the manuscript in revision and may change slightly before publication.

Cut Off by a River

A suspension trail bridge with blue, yellow and green towers spanning a river valley among banana plants, with people crossing
One of the 97 study bridges (Nyakabande–Bitaba), Rwanda. Figure 1 of the manuscript.

More than 80% of Rwandans live in rural, hilly farming communities. When rivers flood, villages lose their route to schools, clinics, markets and their own fields.

The program

The Government of Rwanda and Fika (formerly Bridges to Prosperity) set out to build several hundred trail bridges in four of the five provinces. The study covers 97 of them.

The bridges

Suspended and suspension footbridges, 38 to 156 m long (median 75 m). They carry people, livestock and motorcycles, not cars. Median build time was 98 days, at about $100,000 each, with community members providing much of the unskilled labor.

After handover

Each bridge belongs to the government; district governments maintain it.

Source: Thomas, Brooks, Donovan, Muthike, Mugabo & MacDonald (2026), Bridge building: first-mile transportation infrastructure yields disproportionate gains for isolated communities in Rwanda, manuscript in revision.

3 min. Of the 97 bridges, 74 are suspended, 19 suspension and 4 hybrid. Contrast with Tuesday’s and today’s US examples: here the question is not how to cut emissions from travel, but what happens when people who could not travel at all, part of the year, can.

A Randomized Rollout

Baseline2020–21 Follow-up 1 Follow-up 2 Follow-up 3 Cohort 122 sites Cohort 241 sites Cohort 334 sites bridgeyear 2bridge bridgebridge bridge not yet Year-2 effect: cohort 1 vs. cohort 3 at follow-up 2 (green outlines)

Fika chose the sites. The researchers randomized the order in which they were built, within each of 18 districts. Every site got its bridge, so the comparison is between villages that got theirs earlier and those still waiting.

Map of Rwanda with the 97 bridge sites marked as yellow dots, concentrated in the Western, Southern and Northern provinces
The 97 study bridge sites.
10,167
Households in 290 villages
39,059
Household surveys, 4 yearly rounds

Source: Thomas et al. (2026), manuscript in revision. Pre-analysis plan: Macharia et al. (2022). AEA RCT Registry AEARCTR-0013478.

3 min. This design is a stepped-wedge cluster randomized trial. It answers the usual objection to randomizing infrastructure: no community is denied a bridge, only made to wait its turn, which it would have done anyway. 90% of households were interviewed in all four rounds. COVID-19 slowed the first year of construction, so cohort sizes differ from the plan (17, 35, 45). Ask: why randomize the order instead of comparing bridge villages with villages that never got one?

What Changed Two Years After a Bridge

Table and forest plot of 16 household outcomes in the second year after bridge construction, with consumption, cash crops, land, food security, life satisfaction and secondary school enrollment significantly higher
Year-2 effects on 16 household outcomes, with 95% confidence intervals. Open markers: outcomes not in the pre-analysis plan.
+8.7%
Household consumption ($41.68 a year)
+13.5%
Number of cash crops grown
+4.4 pp
Secondary school enrollment, ages 13–18

Land under cultivation rose 12.2% and food security improved. Income, wages and working outside the village did not change significantly.

The gains came through farming: households could reach fields and markets across the river and grew more crops to sell.

Source: Thomas et al. (2026), manuscript in revision, Figure 2.

3 min. Farm value added rose 10.3% but with p = 0.083. The rise in consumption was in market purchases, not food eaten from the household’s own farm. Consumption is the preferred welfare measure here because income in farming households is seasonal and partly in kind. A companion paper (Brooks et al.) shows households cultivating and renting more land across the river. Note for presenter: the manuscript text gives the food security effect as 0.24 SD and the figure as 0.25 SD.

Is a $100,000 Footbridge Worth It?

Treat each bridge as an investment: $100,000 up front, then each beneficiary household gains $8.12 in year 1 and $41.68 a year after that, for a 40-year design life. Solve for the rate of return r:

100,000 / N = 8.12/(1+r) + Σt=2..40 41.68/(1+r)t

N is the number of households that benefit. WorldPop puts about 16,400 people within 3 km of the average study bridge, or 3,556 households.

Foreign aid projects average about a 20% economic rate of return. A similar bridge study in Nicaragua, at sites with much lower population density, found 19%.

Rate of return by number of beneficiary households

3,556 (within 3 km)
91.3%
2,000
58.6%
1,000
33.3%
691 (Fika’s count of people with no other crossing)
24.3%
555
20%

Every one of the 97 sites has more than 555 households within 3 km. Across sites the return ranges from 47% to 120%; the median site is 79.5%.

Sources: Thomas et al. (2026), manuscript in revision, and Supplementary Tables 2–3; Dalgaard & Hansen (2017) for the aid benchmark; Brooks & Donovan (2020), Econometrica, for Nicaragua.

3 min. Callback to the LCA "functional unit": the answer depends almost entirely on N, how many households a fixed asset serves. Robustness: using the lower end of the 95% confidence interval for the consumption effect ($8.40) gives 29.7%. Maintenance at 2% or 5% of cost a year gives 89.8% and 87.5%. If the effect halves every ten years, 87.0%. A 20- or 30-year life gives the same answer, because at these rates distant years count for little. Students can solve the equation in a spreadsheet with Goal Seek.

Rivers Are Rising

Three line charts for 2000 to 2024 averaged across the bridge sites: annual peak streamflow, number of wet days, and 90th-percentile rainfall on wet days, each with a rising trend line
Averages across the study bridge sites, 2000–2024, with Theil–Sen trend lines and 95% bands.

Peak streamflow

Up 21.3 m³/s per year.

Wet days

About 8 more per decade.

Heavy rainfall

90th-percentile wet-day rainfall up 31.5 mm per decade.

A crossing that was passable most of the year in 2000 floods more often now. The study did not measure days when crossings were impassable, so it cannot say whether the bridges helped more in wetter places.

Source: Thomas et al. (2026), manuscript in revision, Figure 3; method from Macharia et al. (2023).

2 min. All three trends have p < 0.05 (Mann–Kendall). Other Rwandan studies attribute rising runoff to land-use change as well as rainfall. This is the adaptation side of transportation: infrastructure that keeps working as the climate changes.
Discussion · 4 minutes · pairs

A Lane in Houston, a Bridge in Rwanda

  1. Adding lanes to the Katy Freeway made trips slower within three years. Adding a footbridge in Rwanda raised consumption within two. What is different about the two investments?
  2. Consumption rose but income did not change significantly. What explanations fit both results?
  3. The rate of return depends on how many people live nearby. Which communities does that rule leave out, and should it?
  4. What would you measure next?
4 min. For question 1: the freeway added capacity where there was already a road, so new demand filled it; the bridge created access where there was none for part of the year. For question 2, the paper’s explanation is that the gains came through farming (crops, land) and showed up in market purchases; farm income is harder to measure than spending. For question 3: the Nicaragua sites had far fewer people per bridge and a 19% return, close to the aid benchmark.
Part 8

Planes, Ships and Hot Streets

The hard-to-electrify modes, and the city around the road

Aviation and Shipping

Aviation

About 2.4% of global CO2 (2018), but about 3.5% of human-caused warming, because contrails and nitrogen oxides at altitude add to the effect of the CO2. Contrail cirrus is the largest single part of aviation’s warming.

Sustainable aviation fuel: 1.9 million tonnes in 2025, double 2024 and still 0.6% of jet fuel.

Several white contrails crossing an orange sunset sky
Contrails at sunset, Virginia. Photo: Famartin, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Shipping

About 2.9% of global emissions (2018). The International Maritime Organization’s 2023 strategy aims for net zero by around 2050, with cuts of at least 20% by 2030 and 70% by 2040 from 2008.

In October 2025, member states voted to postpone adopting the “Net-Zero Framework,” which would set a fuel standard and a carbon price, by one year. A new attempt is due in December 2026.

A loaded container ship being guided by tugboats
Container ship and tugs, Koper, Slovenia. Photo: Martin Dörsch, CC0.

Sources: Lee et al. (2021), Atmospheric Environment 244:117834; IATA (9 Dec 2025); IMO 2023 GHG Strategy; IMO Fourth GHG Study (2020); Carbon Brief (May 2026).

3 min. Contrail cirrus was about 57% of aviation’s net effective radiative forcing in 2018 in Lee et al. Avoiding the humid layers where persistent contrails form is a cheap, active research area. A Denver–Europe round trip of about 16,000 km at the long-haul factor (148 g per passenger-km) is about 2.4 t CO2e per passenger, about three years of heat lost through Tuesday’s single-pane windows.

Urban Heat and Green Infrastructure

NASA thermal map of Houston with hot red areas in the dense center and cooler areas along vegetated edges
Surface temperature across Houston from NASA’s ECOSTRESS sensor, June 2023. Photo: NASA Scientific Visualization Studio, public domain.

Pavement and roofs absorb sunlight and release heat at night. US cities run about 1–7 °F warmer than surrounding areas by day and 2–5 °F warmer at night.

In 94% of 108 US cities studied, neighborhoods redlined in the 1930s are hotter today than non-redlined ones: on average about 2.6 °C (4.7 °F), and up to 7 °C.

What cools a street

  • Tree canopy and green space
  • Reflective (“cool”) roofs and pavements
  • Less surface parking

Sources: EPA, Learn About Heat Islands; Hoffman, Shandas & Pendleton (2020), Climate 8:12.

3 min. Connect to the environmental justice week. Redlining was the 1930s federal practice of rating neighborhoods by race for mortgage lending. Surface temperature (what the satellite sees) runs hotter than air temperature.

Colorado Requires Transportation Plans to Cut Emissions

Colorado’s GHG Transportation Planning Standard (2021) requires CDOT and the five metropolitan planning organizations to show that their long-range plans reduce greenhouse gas emissions by set amounts.

If a plan falls short, the agency must add mitigation (transit, bike and walking projects, land use changes) or face restrictions on how some funds are spent.

Statewide, transportation emissions in 2023 were about the same as in 2005, while Coloradans drove 54.7 billion vehicle-miles.

Aerial view of a large surface parking lot
Surface parking, Denver area. Photo: Heath Alseike, CC BY 2.0.

Sources: 2 CCR 601-22 (Colorado Transportation Commission, Dec 2021); CDOT (Jul 2025), GHG Planning Standard report; Colorado Energy Office testimony (Mar 2026).

2 min. CDOT’s report itself is inconsistent about whether transportation or electric power is Colorado’s largest source, so the slide does not claim either. The 2030 statewide reduction level is 1.5 million tonnes CO2e (DRCOG’s share 0.82).

Key Takeaways

Buildings are mostly a heat problem

Space and water heating are 61% of home energy. Seal and insulate first, then electrify.

Heat pumps depend on COP and the grid

On Colorado’s 2024 grid a heat pump beats a gas furnace on mild days and loses on the coldest. The 2030 grid changes the answer.

The existing stock is the main job

Half of US homes predate 1980. Codes shape new buildings; performance laws and rental rules reach old ones.

Occupancy and distance matter as much as the vehicle

A full bus or a shared car beats a solo driver; a short trip beats a clean long one.

EVs cut life-cycle emissions by about two-thirds in the US

Even counting the battery. US federal support ended in 2025; Colorado’s continues.

Land use decides how much we drive

New lanes fill up. Nearby destinations, connected streets and safe bike routes reduce driving.

2 min.

Further Reading

Next week: Carbon Markets & Climate Finance, and the Carbon Markets Lab.